By Jef With One F
By Rocks Off
By Chris Lane
By Angelica Leicht
By Corey Deiterman
By Angelica Leicht
By Corey Deiterman
Sketches (For My Sweetheart the Drunk)
Anyone well-versed in the more senseless aspects of rock and roll tragedy ought to be acquainted with Jeff Buckley's abrupt demise. The charmed offspring of vocal gymnast Tim Buckley -- who died of a heroin overdose when his son was a child -- the guy had all the symptoms of inevitable genius, not to mention his dad's multi-octave range. Then, on a May night in Memphis in 1997, 30-year-old Buckley threw it away for an ill-advised (clothed) dip in the churning Mississippi River.
He didn't leave much behind. When his dad died at 28, he already had nine releases to his credit; by 30, Jeff had released only a live EP and a single proper debut, 1994's breathtaking Grace.
Columbia has approached Buckley's posthumous Sketches (For My Sweetheart the Drunk) with a certain amount of caution. In particular, the label has emphasized the artist's lack of say in the two-CD project. (Duh, he's been dead nearly a year.) It's as if Columbia is prepping listeners for a letdown, and apologizing not only to us but to Buckley himself.
In the big picture, though, such damage control is unwarranted, if only because Sketches brings a sense of closure to what's sure to be seen as an unjustly abbreviated legacy. Taken as a whole, the 20-track collection is patchy and unhinged, its production (much of it done with the help of Television alum Tom Verlaine in New York, the rest self-produced) bordering on unlistenable in some instances. But it's worth a pass through the murkiest moments if only to glimpse where Buckley might have been headed.
Compiled by Buckley's mother, Mary Guibert, with help from the singer's close friends Michael Clouse and Chris Cornell, Sketches is just that: a liberal outline of what might or might not have gone into Buckley's second full-length album. The Verlaine-produced songs on the first disc feature Buckley and his band. Things commence on a bold note with "The Sky Is a Landfill," its heavy-handed, vaguely apocalyptic lyrics ("You like to dance to the rolling head of the adulteress") leavened by inspired singing and a forcefully seductive guitar line. Even stronger are the scorching ballad "Everybody Here Wants You" (on which Buckley tackles the role of soul singer to remarkable effect) and "Witches' Rave" (a bouncy but dark number with pillowy falsetto interludes and an enticingly skewed chorus). The more finished material on the first disc lays out an expansion map of sorts for Buckley's plans after Grace -- the tempestuous melding of beauty and brutality, coldness and intimacy, melody and malady.
By contrast, the second CD is more note pad than blueprint; it's made up of four-track demos and reworked versions of tracks from disc one. Inconsistency reigns: A superior version of the previous disc's "Nightmares by the Sea" is followed by a noticeably inferior take of the first CD's "New Year's Prayer," then by a series of unnerving tone poems and shrill noise vignettes. The quasi-spiritual imagery seems to define Buckley as an uncomfortable cross between Nick Drake and Jim Morrison -- weird stuff best reserved for weird states of mind.
But even Sketches' warts are revelatory, as they show the singer struggling to experiment while also satisfying his more conventional rock-star urges. Had fate been kinder, the chances are good that Buckley would've given us plenty more reasons to examine both extremes.
-- Hobart Rowland (***)
Randy Travis's first release for his new label could have been a contender. It could have been a great chance for a favored veteran to reclaim some of the thunder from the hat-wearin' pop artists who pass for "country" these days -- an artistic rebirth, perhaps. Instead, on You and You Alone, one of the genre's most distinctive voices reminds us just why the same-sounding brethren he influenced are so popular in the first place: They still have some life in them.
A bulk of the tracks here -- most maudlin or just plain inferior -- are as dry as the haystack on which Travis sits for the CD cover. Granted, his singing style has always been oil-well-deep and on the less emotive side, but lately his delivery possesses all the passion of a mathematician rattling off equations. And it doesn't help that far too many of the lyrics find Travis in pissin', moanin' and moonin' mode. Either that, or he's trying to turn modest three-minute ditties into statements of major importance (as on the overwrought "Spirit of a Boy, Wisdom of a Man").
A few numbers provide some relief: the buoyant "Stranger in My Mirror," the cautionary tale in "The Hole" and the simple yet elegant cover of "Horse Called Music." But mostly on You and You Alone, Travis makes like the acquaintance you try to avoid, lest he rope you into hearing his latest dull, drawn-out tale of woe. And frankly, it's getting tougher to seem interested. (**)
-- Bob Ruggiero
Dave Matthews Band
Before These Crowded Streets
As commercial pop-rock entities go, the Dave Matthews Band has a lot to recommend itself. Just the idea of a white South African leading a near-superstar multiracial act has cultural merit, and the band's instrumental mix of horns and violin isn't exactly typical of best-selling acts these days.