By Camilo Smith
By Craig Malisow
By Jeff Balke
By Angelica Leicht
By Jeff Balke
By Sean Pendergast
By Sean Pendergast
By Jeff Balke
To the long-suffering employees slaving away in the guts of the HISD's Taj Mahal administration building, President George W. Bush is indeed an education savior.
He freed them from the seven-year reign of Superintendent Rod Paige by boosting him to education secretary. With that appointment, Bush also indirectly provided tickets to Washington for two members of Paige's command staff: Terry Abbott, the $120,000 diploma-less Paige political flack, and Susan Sclafani, the superintendent's top workaholic deputy.
Sclafani unsuccessfully sought the acting superintendency, only to be rebuffed by the board's choice of ambitionless near-future retiree Kaye Stripling. So Susan opted for a ticket on Paige's Cherry Blossom special and the post of "counselor to the secretary." She officially moves out this week to join Abbott, now the press spokesman for Paige in D.C. Sharon Hammond, Paige's HISD secretary, also joins the team in D.C.
With Paige's brain, mouth and penmanship in good hands, the ex-superintendent -- and former TSU dean and football coach -- should be admirably prepared for a successful run as a Washington bureaucrat.
In the Paige team's wake, Stripling announced the new district command structure at a school board retreat several weeks ago. The hierarchy features an ex-trustee, a longtime financial officer and an academic manager who has been responsible for the implementation of the controversial Model-Netics program in the district.
Replacing Sclafani as HISD chief academic officer is Robert Stockwell. He retains his position over the Main Events Management Services that includes the wacky desk manual program sold to Paige by his management guru, former American General CEO Harold Hook. Those services also include Model-Netics, the controversial management language system using oddball catchphrases about trains and seas. It was embraced by Paige and Sclafani several years back and forced down the throats of gagging administrators and principals.
"Leonard's the only one of the three that exhibits remotely human characteristics," snipes one Taj Mahalic, "and he's the bean counter!"
The new lineup gets better reviews from Gayle Fallon,president of the Houston Federation of Teachers. She praises Stockwell as someone "who really knows curriculum" and figures his involvement with Model-Netics was more in the role of playing a good soldier and doing what Paige and Sclafani wanted.
As for Mincberg, Fallon opines that "Cathy has a spine of steel, and that scares some administrators." Although the union's relations with Sclafani were abysmal, Fallon credits Mincberg as "a straight shooter" who honors her commitments.
Chief-of-staff duties now go to Rosalind Young, who will serve as gatekeeper to Stripling, as well as supervising departments including media and information services. Young still has some long-term bureaucratic enemies for the way she hounded former television reporter Sandy Rivera out of the district PR office years ago. Abbott's old press spokesman job is up for grabs.
So why did the board bypass Sclafani for the interim superintendency, effectively forcing her departure? Board president Jeff Shadwick suggests that congeniality, or the lack thereof, might have had something to do with it. One of the criteria for the interim is "who would be most likely to get along with most people in the organization?" says Shadwick. "In other words, whose ascendancy would cause the fewest people to leave."
In addition, had Sclafani gotten the title, many would have seen it as a way to promote her to the top job without a search process -- just as Paige himself was elevated from the board to the top job in 1994.
"She may still have a shot at the full-time superintendency," says Shadwick. "Had she been the interim, we would have heard cries that the deal is cut, that nobody else really has a shot."
The board's final answer turned out to be Stripling, a nonthreatening, well-liked veteran. She took the fall for supervisors in a controversy over alternative teacher certification in the early '90s and then was sent in to clean up the mess as principal at the troubled Rice Middle School. Stripling clearly paid her dues, earning a final glory lap as the interim.
"In getting Kaye Stripling," says Shadwick, "we're trying to really beat the drum on the theme that this is an open process, it's going to be a fair competition, nobody has the inside track. And we accomplished that in picking her."
And the only person the selection chased out of HISD was Sclafani. "I hear people are doing cartwheels in the halls" of the Taj Mahal, chuckles Fallon about Susan's exit.
As the process unfolds, Hispanics demand that one of their own inherit the superintendency. Shadwick says the board will try some new tactics to find a nontraditional type of superintendent. One of the strategies is to forgo a conventional executive headhunting firm. Instead, they'll use a racially diverse group of consultants for the scouting job. While one source says the formula is one white, one black and one brown consultant, Shadwick denies it's that racially cut-and-dried.
"We want an undetermined number of consultants, probably two or three, with the idea being we want to cast nets in as many different directions as possible." He says at least one consultant likely will be Hispanic, and all should have experience with job searches.