Dueling Docs

The city's top MDs collide, but the mayor sides with Shelley

City Councilwoman Dr. Shelley Sekula-Gibbs came into office last year determined to be the authority on all things medical. The only problem was that Houston already had a strong-willed public health director named Dr. Mary Kendrick, who wasn't about to be taken to school by a Clear Lake dermatologist, of all things.

Until the recent budget crunch at City Hall, the doctor duel was pretty much a standoff. As documented previously in the Houston Press (see "Overdose," August 22, 2002), Dr. Shelley drove Dr. Mary to distraction by firing barrages of memos that have been largely ignored, dissed or dismissed by her bureaucratic counterpart.

The councilwoman still rubs plenty of colleagues the wrong way with her doctor shtick, including recently wearing a lab coat to City Council and community meetings. But the balance of power between the two docs is changing. Sekula-Gibbs has found an unlikely ally, Kendrick's boss Mayor Lee Brown. At issue is finding a way to keep city health clinics open despite a lack of municipal funding.

One of Sekula-Gibbs's most persistent campaigns has been to convert some city clinics into Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs). Kendrick previously opposed that change on the grounds it undercuts the city's mission to provide preventive rather than primary health care.

The FQHCs are run by nonprofit private medical agencies and are funded by federal grants. They provide routine treatment for minor illnesses and are touted as a way of taking pressure off public hospitals. More to the point, the federal dollars would also take financial pressure off the cash-strapped city, which faces the permanent closing of at least one of its seven facilities, the Riverside Clinic in the Third Ward.

Although Kendrick chose not to discuss her position, which is at odds with Brown's, a health department source explains it this way: "Her feeling is when you get into the crush of providing health care, what gets left on the table is the preventive side. Given the choice between treating six cases of strep throat or a family planning case or a two-year-old [child's] developmental assessment, the family planning and developmental assessment are going to go out the door."

Riverside has been closed for nearly a year, awaiting extensive structural renovations. When the mayor asked each department for budget cuts, Kendrick initially proposed permanently closing the Riverside and Magnolia clinics and consolidating staff in the remaining clinics to improve services and cut down on appointment backlogs. That was later amended to keep the Magnolia Clinic open but shutter Riverside.

That gave Sekula-Gibbs her opening to pitch the mayor on converting the closed clinic into an FQHC.

"The point is that Riverside is closed and the money is simply not there to reopen it, even though the services are desperately needed," says the councilwoman, who is working with Brown's Chief Administrative Officer Al Haines on options to reopen the clinic. The councilwoman argues that the best choice is for the city to spend $500,000 or so to renovate Riverside and then allow it to be used by an FQHC called South Central Community Health Center.

"The amount and efficiency of care that can be delivered through a private clinic that's got this broad-based leveraged support is tremendous," explains Sekula-Gibbs. "I think we just have to be open-minded and say we just can't ignore any possibility to improve health care in neighborhoods where it's lacking."

The councilwoman compares the available federal funds to "low-hanging fruit," saying that "you need to just take advantage of these dollars."

Brown's chief of staff, Steve Tinnermon, accompanied Sekula-Gibbs last week on visits to community agencies that have applied for federal clinic status.

The mayor made it clear to his staff that he did not want to be caught in the position of having to cut health services for poor constituents. As a way to avoid closing clinics, he's backed the initiative of Sekula-Gibbs, an at-large councilmember.

The Third Ward's representative on council, District D's Ada Edwards, is firmly in Kendrick's camp. She says neither she nor Councilwoman Carol Alvarado, whose District I includes the clinic, was consulted. Likewise, it came as a shock to activists in the neighborhoods served by Riverside.

"We've been telling the community to hang in there 'cause the clinic's going to come back," says Edwards. She's bitter that the budget is being balanced on the backs of children, the sick, the poor and the disabled.

"The easiest way is just to cut it and say, 'We're going to let the feds come in and take over our responsibility,' " Edwards says. "If that happens, it'll happen over my loud voice saying, 'This is betrayal.' The community deserves to have both."

Edwards echoes Kendrick's position that preventive care, including family planning, juvenile diabetes detection and immunizations, will inevitably take a backseat if the clinics are privatized.

"Federal clinics I have no problem with, but they will not provide prevention," insists Edwards. "If we take that away from the community, bad [nutritional and behavioral] habits will go on generation to generation." According to Edwards, the work that has been done in her district to try to educate people to make better choices and take command of their lives "will be marginalized at best and eroded if we're not careful."

1
 
2
 
All
 
Next Page »
 
My Voice Nation Help
0 comments
 
Loading...