By Chris Lane
By Jeff Balke
By Aaron Reiss
By Angelica Leicht
By Dianna Wray
By Aaron Reiss
By Camilo Smith
By Craig Malisow
Bell, a witty, irascible musician who played bass guitar behind iconoclastic troubadour Townes Van Zandt and Third Ward bluesman Lightnin' Hopkins, struck a deal with Brenham Brewery to help create his new draft beer. A test keg of the brew, which has a reddish tinge and what Bell describes as a "hoppy" flavor, was a big hit with patrons, he said.
Last December, Bell and some friends were relaxing at his bar when he was inspired to name his beer. "I've always sold Lone Star and Shiner Bock draft beer. I mixed the two together and that was it. I said Starbock would be a cool name for a beer," Bell said. "A couple of weeks later I still thought it was a cool idea, and I applied for a trademark with the Treasury Department in February."
Plans progressed, and the trademark process was sailing along, until the situation suddenly changed in July. Another brewer -- one not even involved in producing beer -- had taken a keen interest in the small bar's efforts to create Starbock.
Starbucks Coffee Company weighed in with all the subtlety of its corporate-colossus status. All Bell had to do to make Starbucks happy was immediately drop his beer's name and destroy all materials containing images of its trademark.
Do that soon, the corporation ordered, or face "other necessary legal action."
Bell doesn't take well to intimidation. The crusty bar owner had operated the original Old Quarter bar in downtown Houston from 1966 to 1973, during the city's Texas music renaissance. After that, he thought he was out of the music business for good. But he reopened in Galveston in 1996, just around the corner from the island landmark, the Grand 1894 Opera House on Postoffice Street.
He also believed he'd complied with all the legal requirements in his quest for the new quaff. Bell sent a copy of his Starbock logo -- a blue star with red lettering surrounded by smaller stars -- to the trademark office. When the feds said he couldn't trademark the word beer, he took care of the problem by refiling one set of papers.
In fact, correspondence received by Bell earlier this month from the Trademark Assistance Center indicated his application was quickly reaching the final approval stage. It said that the government attorney reviewing his case found "no similar registered or pending mark which would bar registration" under the Trademark Act.
Starbucks thinks otherwise.
Julia Anne Matheson, the attorney representing Starbucks, responded to phone calls and an e-mail containing a list of questions from the Press by referring all inquiries to Starbucks headquarters in Seattle.
Matheson, of the law firm of Finnegan Henderson Farabow Garrett & Dunner LLP of Palo Alto, California, has sent several notices to Bell since May. Starbucks received its name and logo trademarks in 1997.
"Given the undeniable similarity in the appearance and pronunciation of the Starbock and Starbocks marks Starbucks is understandably concerned that your use of the Starbock Beer mark will generate confusion in the marketplace as to the origin of the parties' respective products, [and] misappropriate the goodwill in the Starbucks Marks that our client has labored long and hard to establish," Matheson said in a May 22 letter.
Bell says he verbally sparred with Matheson in a phone conversation in July, during which he claims she suggested the name could be changed from Starbock to Bockstar. "Ms. Matheson said about ten times that I cannot win or I cannot beat them, and I said, 'I'm just trying to make beer, not win something.' I also asked her what she meant in her letters by settling this 'amicably.'
"She said 'amicably' is for me to cease and desist and destroy all items with the trademark and go away. I said, 'I'm not going to cease and desist,' and the last thing she said was, 'You'll be hearing from me.' "
For his part, Bell -- who likes to point out the fact that being a recovering alcoholic has not affected his ability to pour beer -- is puzzled that Starbucks has set its sights on a small bar. The coffee giant reported $3.3 billion in consolidated net revenues in a ten-month period ending in July. Old Quarter receipts on a typical night might barely buy a round of Starbucks decaf lattes for the Houston Astros.
"They think I used their name to come up with mine, and that's just plain wrong," Bell said. "They think the whole world revolves around their corporation. Maybe they can buy [the name] from me. I just want to make my beer and have them leave me alone."
Yet several Houston legal experts interviewed by the Press say that these kinds of trademark disputes do not often result in a stunning victory for the little guy.