College Immaterial for High School Students in Vocational Training

Good paying jobs, no huge loan burdens, exciting course work — the new vo-tech attracts more and more hi-tech students

Ask 19-year-old high-school senior Andy Garza about his career plans, and he's anything but vague. Petroleum process technician, he'll say, then quickly add: "All it takes is a two-year degree — and the pay, I mean, it's good."

Teacher Reginald Christy will head the country's first Academy for Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology, opening next fall at Charles Milby High in Houston ISD.
Daniel Kramer
Teacher Reginald Christy will head the country's first Academy for Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology, opening next fall at Charles Milby High in Houston ISD.
Kids in Katy ISD's increasingly popular emergency medical technology class can earn as much as $15 an hour right out of high school.
Daniel Kramer
Kids in Katy ISD's increasingly popular emergency medical technology class can earn as much as $15 an hour right out of high school.

Indeed, starting pay is as much as $20 an hour, and it's not at all uncommon to draw a six-figure salary after just a couple years on the job, according to Garza's teacher, Reginald Christy, at Charles Milby High in the Houston Independent School District. Next fall, thanks to a $200,000 industry grant, Milby will open the country's first Academy for Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology.

Milby's student body is 99 percent black and Hispanic and 79 percent poor. Last year, a Johns Hopkins University study dubbed it a "dropout factory" where more than 40 percent of freshmen don't make it to their senior year. The new petroleum academy, which will teach students about lucrative careers in an industry clamoring for technical workers, could prove a powerful incentive for kids to stay in school.

In Spring ISD, 17-year-old senior Jerod Redmon is wrapping up his second year in the automotive program at Carl Wunsche Sr. High. "Before I started, I didn't even know how to change oil," he says. Now he's a specialist in steering, suspension and brakes.

Through an internship program at his school, Jerod landed a part-time job as a service adviser handling customer complaints at DeMontrond Cadillac in Conroe. He plans to continue working at the dealership while attending community college in the fall, with the long-term goal of transferring to the University of Houston for a business degree.

"If it wasn't for Wunsche," he says, "I'd probably still be working at Movie Tavern making popcorn."

When Lily Espinosa signed up for the emergency medical technology class at her high school, she wasn't sure if she really had what it took to realize her dream of becoming an emergency room doctor.

Then one day several months ago, after spending hours interning in the back of an ambulance, the 17-year-old was making the rounds at Memorial Hermann Katy when a man went into cardiac arrest. She revived him several times with CPR, but he died in her arms.

"If you're an EMT," she says, "you have to have the stomach to see dead bodies, blood everywhere, trauma."

Lily learned that day that she has the stomach for it.

In the coming weeks, while still a high-school senior at Morton Ranch High in Katy ISD, Lily will become certified as an emergency medical technician, a job with a starting pay as high as $15 an hour. She plans to work part-time as an EMT while earning a degree in biology at Baylor University on her way to medical school.

Andy, Jerod and Lily are the new faces of vocational education, once considered the B-track for high school kids lacking the brains and desire to go to college.

Sure, many school districts still offer wood shop, now dubbed "trade and industrial," and home economics, known today as "family and consumer sciences." Even the old familiar names such as "vocational" or "vo-tech" have recently been scrapped and replaced with "career and technical ­education."

But it's not just the names that have changed. School districts across the Houston area are expanding and modernizing their vocational programs, constructing multimillion-dollar facilities and placing a greater emphasis on kids gaining job skills and industry certifications while still in high school.

"The word 'vocational' denotes low wage, blue collar," says Rosena Garcia, director of career and technical education programs at Houston ISD. "We're trying to get away from that stigma."
_____________________

Visit college campuses with your kids; get them enrolled in Advanced Placement classes early; have them participate in extracurricular activities; make sure they do volunteer work — and not just for a few months during their senior year.

David Johnston, a college counselor at Lee High in Houston ISD, offered these tips last month during one in a series of community meetings on "what parents should be doing right now to get children ready for college."

The kids were only in fifth grade.

Houston ISD's slogan used to be "Expectation: Graduation." Seeking to raise the bar higher than merely getting through high school, in 2006 district superintendent Abelardo Saavedra changed it to "College-Bound Culture."

But what is college? During his 90-minute­ presentation, Johnston never mentioned technical schools, certification programs or two-year community colleges. Rather, he stressed the importance of pre-AP and AP classes, the PSAT and class rankings: all key factors for gaining admission into traditional four-year ­institutions.

According to U.S. Census data, a person with a bachelor's degree, on average, earns twice as much income as somebody with only a high school diploma. But more than 40 percent of freshmen at four-year colleges don't graduate in six years, and most dropouts leave with a mountain of debt, Marty Nemko, an author and career coach, wrote earlier this month in The Chronicle of Higher Education.

"College is a wise choice for far fewer people than are currently encouraged to consider it," Nemko concludes in the article, titled "America's Most Overrated Product: The Bachelor's Degree."

In Texas, the high-school dropout rate for African Americans and Hispanics ranges as high as 50 percent. Research shows that a mix of career and technical education classes and academic courses lowers the dropout rate. A 1998 University of Michigan study found that high-risk students were eight to ten times less likely to drop out in 11th and 12th grades if they enroll in a career and technical education program instead of a general program.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next Page >>
 
  • Kate 07/23/2010 8:27:00 PM

    Wow, thanks for sharing this article. I went to school at Concordia University (http://discoverconcordia.edu), but prior to being accepted, I didn't know what I wanted to do - I decided on a degree program in the midst of my school work. Having high school training for career programs would be such a great asset to many schools.

  • jim 06/04/2008 6:14:00 PM

    Chris Barbic speaks of tracking students, but YES and similar charter schools do just that. They are not charged with educating all children living within a certain geographical zone. If even Milby, the Johns Hopkins tabbed "dropout factory," was allowed to pre-qualify its student body, all of our schools would achieve like academic success. But, what about the rest of our shared human existence? What happens to them?

  • Dawn 05/20/2008 10:09:00 PM

    I think the article could have done without the comments from Stephen Klineberg. I don't think he understands the demands of a vocational career. Constant learning is critical and these are the jobs that are often on the front line of chaning technology. As for being obsolete, I'd like to see him tell his plumber that. I think there would be a lot of laughter.

  • B 05/16/2008 4:48:00 PM

    I went to college (undergrad and grad school) because I loved school and loved learning. My older brother is a college dropout because, as smart as he was, the traditional school setting never held his interest. Now, all these years later, he lives hand-to-mouth while I have a relatively comfortable existence. People with college degrees don't fare better statistically because that piece of paper is some sort of Willy Wonka magic ticket; we tend to fare better because there's a huge bias in society toward those who went to a "real" college. Just because I had the patience to sit in a classroom for years on end, I am somehow better than my hairdresser, my mechanic, a contractor, EMT or pharmacy tech? Every day that goes by, we trust those with vocational careers -- to handle our vehicles, our children, our planes, our homes, our medicines. Yet, they're still regarded as second-class and/or blue collar. It's an embarrassment. I wish these high schools had been around when my brother was going to school... and I hope administrators, legislators and the like will really start to understand that it takes *all* types to make our society safe and viable. As a society, we will never truly advance unless we are all educated, but what matters most isn't a college degree, but critical thinking, analytic skills and the desire to learn. And really, when is the last time anyone saw those things in your 'typical' college freshman?

  • Sue 05/16/2008 2:35:00 PM

    My youngest who is now 25 yrs., went to a tech. school after getting his G.E.D. He went through San Jacinto College to learn to be a Machinist. The program was suspended the year after he graduated. We still need machinist and tool and die makers for manufacturing! These are highly technical jobs. All products start with manufacturing! No wonder those jobs are going to China. There is no one left here in the U.S. with the skills. Thanks for listening.

  • Anse 05/15/2008 12:23:00 PM

    Thank you so much for publishing this. HISD's motto, "Creating a College-Bound Culture," is a slap in the face to the majority of our students who have no college aspirations. We have radically distorted the place of public education in society; our job should be to help students realize their dreams, not dictate what those dreams ought to be. I think some of us in our profession (I work in HISD myself) have attempted to right past wrongs by going overboard. Many students lacked opportunities in the old days and were shifted to vocational classes without much consideration for their wishes or natural talents. We're doing the same thing today, under the fallacy that every young person should go to college. Working in the trades is not a sign of failure. For quite a lot of people, including many in my own family, these jobs provide good salaries and personal fulfillment. HISD must address this issue if it really wants to deal with the drop-out rate.

  • pat 05/14/2008 10:42:00 PM

    Thank you - this was an excellent article. When in high school, I knew that I had no idea what I wanted as a career, so although I went to the University of Illinois, I never graduated. This may have been different if I had some hands on experience prior to attending the University. Surprisingly, after 30 years, without a BA, I have found that career working in higher ed!

  • Anse 05/14/2008 4:52:00 PM

    Thank you for this article. I'm a teacher in HISD, and I have voiced this very concern many times to colleagues and administrators. The motto "Creating a College-Bound Culture" is an insult to the vast majority of our students who do not have those aspirations. We wonder why we're losing so many of our students, and this is precisely the reason. We forget that a student's dreams are his or her own, not ours, and if vocational and technical training brings out their unique talents, we should support that.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy