The Horse Whisperer, the latest film from Robert Redford -- and the first of his directorial efforts in which he also stars -- could almost serve as a compendium of Redford's best and worst tendencies. It features his eye for gorgeous, pictorial vistas ... his straightforward narrative approach ... and, most importantly, his understanding of actors. Yet its shortcomings keep it from the level of Quiz Show, still by far his best piece of filmmaking.
After a brief dream sequence, the film shows upper-crust adolescent Grace MacLean (Scarlett Johansson) preparing to go for a ride on Pilgrim, her beloved horse. Everything is too idyllic: It's clear that something bad is going to happen, and indeed it does. In a freak accident, both horse and rider are horribly injured.
The lower half of Grace's right leg needs to be amputated, and Pilgrim is way past the normal threshold for euthanasia. But, against all medical opinion, Annie (Kristin Scott Thomas), Grace's strong-willed mother, refuses to have the horse put down without Grace's consent.
Grace's psychological recuperation from her surgery is far from smooth. Robert (Sam Neill), her lawyer father, tends to coddle her, while the far more brittle Annie, a high-powered magazine editor, seems to have taken the notion of tough love to heart.
When Grace finally goes to visit Pilgrim, she is further traumatized by his psychological and physical disfigurement. (The sheer insanity of Annie and Robert taking her to the stable without first warning her about his condition is acknowledged in the dialogue but never really explained.)
The unflappable Annie simply directs the resources of her magazine staff to the task of researching equine rehabilitation. When she sees a picture of grizzled, handsome Tom Booker (Redford) -- a so-called "horse whisperer" -- she inexplicably fixates on him as her one salvation. Over Booker's objections, Annie packs up Grace and Pilgrim and drives them to his isolated Montana ranch to enlist the horse whisperer's aid in bringing Pilgrim around.
There is one possible explanation for Annie's behavior, though the film doesn't seem to hint at it: That grizzled, handsome picture of grizzled, handsome Tom Booker doesn't so much engage Annie's maternal instincts as her romantic yearnings. And, sure enough, Annie and Tom are pretty shortly headed for some steamy clinches, even though the movie makes it look like a total surprise to Annie.
There are a dozen log lines that could have been used to pitch The Horse Whisperer -- Ordinary Equine People or The Bridges of Some Montana County or The Horse with No Face or Hot to Trot 2. It basically combines the family psychodrama of Ordinary People, Redford's Oscar-winning directorial debut, with the middle-aged romance of The Bridges of Madison County, whose screenwriter, Richard LaGravenese, also co-wrote Horse Whisperer -- surely no coincidence.
"Middle-aged romance" may not be an entirely fair phrase here: JulyNovember would be more accurate, since Redford is pretty much past the "middle" that Scott Thomas hasn't even reached yet. Like Paul Newman and Clint Eastwood, the star has the ability to pack on the years without losing his romantic viability. Still, for many there will be something off-putting about the age difference.
But a bigger problem for the film derives from Redford's curious notion of his own image. After Quiz Show and -- for all its flaws (basically its final third) -- Ordinary People, it's clear that the man is an intelligent director. But, as a producer and a star, he's always shied away from portraying negative characters -- or even characters with negative qualities. (Remember when he was replaced on The Verdict because he wanted to soften the hero's flaws to the point where his "redemption" would be meaningless?)
If there's anything that grows cloying during The Horse Whisperer's leisurely two-hour-45-minute expanse, it's the sheer wonderfulness of Tom Booker. Annie is often intolerable and irritating; Grace is troubled; and Robert ... well, Robert just seems like a bit of a wimp. But Tom is Mr. Macho Self-Assurance, with a contempo glaze of Self-Effacing Male Liberalism. The guy simply doesn't do anything even mildly wrong or unlikable or flawed in nearly three damned hours.
It's a curious contrast to the film's portrayal of Annie, who gets a monopoly on bad traits -- echoes (again) of Ordinary People. At the same time, there's nothing new or provocative about her thorniness: Compare, for example, Susan Sarandon's character in the imperfect, but way edgier, Lorenzo's Oil.
Horse Whisperer may appeal to teenage girls with horse fetishes, or to swoony Redford fans in need of a fantasy. But at the final accounting, it's nothing more than a very long movie about someone, literally and metaphorically, having to get back up on a horse.
The Horse Whisperer.
Directed by Robert Redford. With Redford, Kristin Scott Thomas, Scarlett Johansson and Sam Neill.
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.