The first thought you have while watching The Next Best Thing is "Was Madonna always this bad an actress?" It's a question that soon fades from consciousness to be replaced by "Was Rupert Everett always this bad an actor?" and "Was John Schlesinger always this bad a director?"
Since the answers to the last two questions are resoundingly "No" and "No," we will give Ms. Pop Diva the benefit of the doubt, though the thudding awfulness of her work in The Next Best Thing does recall her wretched performance as the accused murder-by-pussy defendant in 1993's Body of Evidence. But nobody involved will want to make this banal "comedy" a highlight of their résumé not if they have any sense. The one exception could be screenwriter Tom Ropelewski, whose brief résumé starts with the third-rate thriller The Kiss and proceeds downhill from there, believe it or not.
To be fair, however, let's spread the "credit" around. What was Schlesinger -- whose classics stretch as far back as Billy Liar, Darling, Marathon Man and Midnight Cowboy -- thinking?
Madonna plays Abbie, a Los Angeles yoga instructor with a penchant for picking the wrong guys. When her latest two-year affair, with egocentric record producer Kevin (Michael Vartan), goes the way of all the others, she seeks comfort from her best friend, Robert (Everett), a gay landscape architect. Not too long thereafter, she and Robert get drunk and have a one-night stand. And not long after that, she realizes she's pregnant. After minimal shilly-shallying, she and Robert decide to raise the child together without getting married or pretending that their deep friendship is anything other than what it is.
Ka-blam! Five or six years pass. Sam (Malcolm Stumpf), their son, has grown into a thoroughly normal, likable moppet. But trouble enters paradise when Abbie finally meets Mr. Right -- wealthy, handsome, understanding businessman Ben (Benjamin Bratt) -- and decides to get married. Emotional and legal chaos ensue.
The gay-man-sets-up-house-with-female-pal story is nothing new, dating back at least as far as 1978's A Different Story, which itself was no great shakes. And in light of developments like California's anti-same-sex-marriage referendum, the issue of gays' legal rights continues to be of great importance. But the film never really deals with anything: Its problems are unclearly presented and its solutions forced, in large part because the characters are so ill-conceived.
Even before his public breakthrough with My Best Friend's Wedding, Everett had given a series of excellent performances, starting as long ago as 1983, in Another Country. Occasionally he is able to make Robert appealing, but not for long. Ropelewski's comic dialogue is so arch, so poorly written, that it defeats even Everett's great talent. What's more, for the most part the film fails to give us any reason to care about these people. Abbie is simply dull; Ben is an idealized Perfect Man, i.e., a cipher. Robert appears to be an absolutely flawless father to Sam, as though we would lose all sympathy if his parenting were even a little flawed.
The filmmakers bend over so far backward to set up their climactic situation that they suck the life out of the characters. Worse, they add complications to the plot in the final half hour that require Robert to suddenly act like a bastard and a moron and then they fail to do anything with those complications. A minor character reappears in a dramatic Paul Drake-like courtroom moment, then is limply dispensed with later through a single line of dialogue.
In order to give the appearance of dramatic complexity, there are two hackneyed subplots that also serve no function: the father who can't deal with his son being gay, and the buddy who has died of AIDS. As the latter's lover, Doogie Howser shows up once every 20 minutes or so, as if to remind us (ineffectively) of a more sober reality. And to make this thread even worse, a big deal is made of the fact that the dead guy's favorite song was Don MacLean's "American Pie," a detail that presumably has more to do with setting up Madonna's remake of the song than with its dramatic value.
Now I will confess that I liked "American Pie" for about a week and a half after it initially came out. But it doesn't take long for its dopey, pretentious lyrics and cutesy-poo internal rhymes to wear thin. And while I realize that human nature is infinite in its variety, that there are, as absurdist rockers Ween would have it, "many colors in the homo rainbow," and that any simple notions about the superiority of gay aesthetic preferences are doubtless a form of sexist stereotyping, I still have to wonder in amazement: a gay man whose favorite song is "American Pie"?! I'm surprised that the rest of the gay characters in the film didn't die of embarrassment when that irritating ditty takes on the function of an emotionally charged epitaph. While there is much laughter to be had at The Next Best Thing, I counted one intentional chuckle. The rest of the laughs are strictly at the participants' expense.
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.