Less funny than her worst SNL sketch, Girl Most Likely strands Kristen Wiig in a dreadful, disingenuous city-vs.-suburbs comedy that mercilessly mocks New Jersey before turning around and celebrating its provincial trashiness over the hoity-toity snootiness of Manhattan. Fired from her job and dumped by her boyfriend, once-promising playwright Imogene (Wiig) fakes a suicide attempt that lands her in the care of her casino-loving Ocean City mom (Annette Bening). There, stuck living with her simpleton brother (Christopher Fitzgerald), Ralph, and her mother's new beau (Matt Dillon)-- who claims to be a CIA agent and time-travelling samurai--Imogene rants about her hometown before learning that her long-gone dad is actually alive, thus sparking a quest for reunion. Wiig's riffing falls flat, and her character’s journey of self-discovery, which also involves falling for a convenient hunk (Darren Criss), is composed of desperate gags, be it a round of drunken barroom dancing or Ralph donning a homemade, bullet-proof, human-size crab shell. It’s a humorless, regressive ode to staying true to your roots even if that means eschewing bigger, brighter horizons, replete with a recurring retro gag that-- alongside last month's This Is the End--confirms that, at least as ironic punchlines, the Backstreet Boys really are back.
Shari Springer Berman, Robert PulciniKristen Wiig, Matt Dillon, Natasha Lyonne, Annette Bening, Darren Criss, June Diane Raphael, Michelle Hurd, Nathan Corddry, Mickey SumnerMichelle MorganLionsgate/Roadside Attractions