Apparently Playing Organ 100 Years Ago Could Kill You

Apparently Playing Organ 100 Years Ago Could Kill You

My day gig is as a clerk in pretty much Houston's last full-service sheet music store, so if you ever want to come down and comment in person I'm there most days explaining to people the difference between a violin and a fiddle. The difference is no one gets mad when you spill beer on a fiddle.

One of the more interesting aspects of my job is that I get obscure music professional publications, and on the rare occasion when it's not so busy I'll flip through them. Last month we got an issue of The American Organist which has been providing church organists with church organ-related articles for 140 freakin' years!

I discovered reading this issue that playing the organ can apparently kill you. Though it doesn't happen so often these days, an article on the last page of the magazine revealed that a century or so back at least seven people died in the middle of performance from ailments brought about from over-exertion while playing.

In a move that can only be described as an attempt at humor by a capricious god, Professor Henry A. Foster, the organist at St. Andrew's Church in Meriden, CT, was playing "Te Deum" on February 5, 1888 when he was struck with an immediate paralysis and had to be carried home, the entire left side of his body immobilized. Though an exact death date resulting form the incident wasn't recorded, The New York Times reported his recovery as doubtful.

God does tend to be pretty attendant in His house. Another man, Dr. Clare W. Beams, said in his life that he wished to die in the midst of music. He got his wish on June 12, 1887 when he suddenly collapsed while playing the Sunday service at First Reformed Church of Nyack, NY. Dr. Beams had suffered a heart condition all his life, and just before he passed with his last performance unfinished remarked, "I feel it coming now. The end is very near this time."

An ironically macabre organist death happened in Paris of that same year at the church of St.-Honore d'Eylau. A funeral was in full swing, and one M. Covin was engaged to send off the deceased with an original funeral dirge he had been playing after a soulful rendition of "Dies Irae." Suddenly the music stopped, and after a few moments of awkward silence someone had noticed that Covin had fallen to the floor, senseless. It was eventually determined that he had died of an aortic aneurysm.

At least Leopold de Grandval of St. Michael's Church in Jersey City, N.J., finished the funeral he was playing in 1902 and decided he could use a little practice. Moments later, the sexton noticed silence and found Grandval dead at his keyboard.

Story continues on the next page.


One of the most tragic deaths of an organist in concert was that of Louis Vierne in 1937, a man who God made very talented then promptly kicked in the balls at every opportunity to make up for it. He was born almost completely blind due to cataracts, but managed to learn to play and even compose with Braille. His skill was good enough to earn him a spot as Charles-Marie Widor's assistant, basically the Jimi Hendrix of organists, and he eventually took up the principal organist position at Notre-Dame de Paris.

Despite all this awesomeness, his life was constantly trying to punish him for daring to overcome his adversities. His wife divorced him, and he lost both his brother and son in the trenches of World War I. The organ at Notre Dame was in such poor condition he actually had to go on a fundraising concert tour just to repair the damn thing, and just when he finally got an instrument worthy of his talent a street accident broke his leg so badly doctors thought they were going to have to amputate it. Vierne kept his leg, but to took him a year to relearn how to use the pedals on the organ he had just toured the world to rebuild.

On June 2, 1937, he was giving his 1750th concert at Notre-Dame when a stroke or heart attack took him as he sat preparing to play improvisations on his "Stele Pour un Enfant Defunt." Reports indicate that "He suddenly pitched forward, and fell off the bench as his foot hit the low 'E' pedal of the organ. He lost consciousness as the single note echoed throughout the church."

Like Dr. Beams, Vierne hoped to die onstage, seated at his beloved organ. Still, it seemed a poor way to pay the man back for restoring the damn thing.

Jef has a new story, a tale of headless strippers and The Rolling Stones, available now in Broken Mirrors, Fractured Minds. You can also connect with him on Facebook.


Nas' Biggest Fan Lives In Houston, With the Tattoos to Prove It The Top Five Most Disastrous Musician Interviews Ever The 10 Suckiest Bands of the '00s Today's Musicians Have All Lost Their Damn Minds

Sponsor Content


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >