Murder by Numbers
Thank you for purchasing the How to Write a Phat Hip-hop Eulogy starter kit. Enclosed you will find the following:
Ten sample eulogies, including those used to mourn rap superstars such as the Notorious B.I.G., Jam Master Jay, Old Dirty Bastard and more!
Fifty inspiring ready-to-use lyrical quotations. Sample (from Dr. Dre's "What's the Difference?"): "Eazy, I'm still wit you / Fuck the beef, nigga, I miss you / And that's just bein' real wit you."
A free collector's edition R.I.P. [insert name here] T-shirt with erasable calligraphy pen.
A short primer on hip-hop funeral etiquette. Includes tips on pouring out liquor (spill only premium licks for A-list artists like Tupac; any screw-cap malt liquor will do for rabble like Soulja Slim) as well as a fold-out calendar with helpful hints on how to plan your retaliatory killing.
Eulogy template capable of handling all the expired rappers on your list!
Good. Now let's get started. After all, another hip-hop artist will be dead before you finish reading this sentence. (Damn, there went one of the guys from Three Six Mafia.) We'll begin with the basic eulogy template to help you organize your thoughts:
Real name: DeShaun Holton
Stage name(s): Proof, Big Proof, Dirty Harry.
Playas: Eminem, D12, Obie Trice, Dr. Dre, 50 Cent, G-Unit.
Hatas: Insane Clown Posse, Murder Inc., Benzino, surly bouncers at sketchy Detroit nightclubs.
Albums: D12: Devil's Night (2001), D12 World (2004). Solo: Searching for Jerry Garcia (2005). Various basement tapes and compilation records. Inevitable posthumous album sure to come.
Personal record label: Iron Fist Records.
Movies: 8 Mile (as "Lil' Tic"), The Longest Yard (as "basketball convict").
He/she got their start: Hosting and participating in freestyle battles at the Hip-Hop Shop in Detroit.
Time of death: April 11, 2006, 4:30 a.m.
Place: Triple C Club, 8 Mile Road, Detroit.
Method (e.g., gun, knife, chain saw, hot grits, autoerotic asphyxiation): Multiple gunshots.
His/her death was a) senseless; b) untimely; c) fodder for right-wing parasites to chastise hip-hop: Yes, you betcha, tune in to Fox News.
His/her death will a) be remembered by next Thursday; b) boost record sales; c) inspire a tribute song: Maybe, probably, without a doubt.
He/she went out like a) a soldier; b) a limp-wristed Sally; c) anybody else hear that loud bang? Soldier. If (allegedly) pistol-whipping someone, then shooting them in the head while they're on the ground just seconds before you catch a few yourself is soldierly.
Why this hip-hop death is different: He shot first.
Good. Now you're ready to put the "fun" back into "funeral." Using the lessons in this starter kit, you're guaranteed to be the life of the afterlife party or your money back! Go ahead, give it your best shot (so to speak):
DeShaun Holton was many things to many people. He was a devoted forefather to Detroit hip-hop, talented musician to his fans and loyal friend to his, uh, friends. Others knew him as Mekhi Phifer's character in 8 Mile, the third verse on "Purple Pills" or, most commonly, That Guy Standing Next to Eminem.
To me, he was just Proof.
The only member of D12 anyone recognized who wasn't blond or the chubby dude from Celebrity Fit Club. But let's be honest. There's no way D12 sells a shit ton of records, plays arena tours and gets the money shot on the cover of Rolling Stone without Angry White Boy No. 1.
Then again, Marshall Mathers would probably be slinging M&Ms at the Circle K right now if not for Proof and the gang. After all, it was Proof who befriended Eminem during the epic freestyle battles at the Hip-Hop Shop later immortalized in 8 Mile. The truth is, nobody buys ivory in this business unless it's surrounded by some credible ebony. And, a long time before Dr.-Dre-Come-Lately solidified Slim Shady's hip-hop cred, there was Bizarre, Kuniva, Kon Artis, Swifty and Proof.
D12 is -- or at least was -- the self-deprecating cheese to Eminem's cracker in a genre dominated by opulent posturing and mean muggin'. 50 Cent would gladly take nine more bullets before you'd see him and G-Unit sashaying on MTV in mariachi costumes. But as hilarious as the video for "My Band" was, the song underscored D12's frustration with being a side act of the Eminem Show.
By all accounts, Marshall and DeShaun were close. Proof was even the best man at Eminem's ill-advised re-wedding a few months back. But he nevertheless spent his moments in the spotlight lingering in the shadow of a lunar eclipse.
Proof was considered one of the best hype men in the game -- a somewhat dubious honor akin to being the fastest tire changer in Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s pit crew -- but he was no slouch with a microphone either. His gritty flow -- more Wu-Tang than Motown -- earned him props from The Source and the now defunct Blaze magazine back when most people thought "D12" was the number that sunk their battleship.
Even after he hit the limelight, Proof wasn't your run-of-the-mill charity case hanging on to a famous friend's bootstraps just so that superstar could provide proof, as it were, that he remembered where he came from.
In the end, Proof provided his own. He was presumably keeping it real by frequenting a dodgy Detroit nightclub well past closing time. As a result, his ear to the streets ended up in a pool of blood.
Beirut has nothing on Detroit. It's a broken-down, hollowed-out Ford Pinto of a town erected atop skyscraping cinder blocks on the shores of Lake Michigan. Spend more than three days in Detroit and you'll be begging someone to put a bullet in your head. But misery loves good company. The city has seen more than its share of stellar homegrown talent -- Marvin Gaye, Aaliyah, J-Dilla and now Proof -- meet an unceremonious demise.
The obvious question -- asked at any funeral -- is the big W. Why Proof? Isn't that like taking out a member of the Family Stone when the only person anyone really hates is Sly? But there is no place for reason in the world of rhyme. In this particular scenario, the equation wasn't complicated. Famous rapper plus liquor plus concealed weapon permit divided by Detroit times pi equals dead.
Same shit, different dude. Murder isn't a by-product of hip-hop so much as it is a reflection of the atmosphere from which it's spawned. But one thing in particular separates Proof's death from the ghosts of hip-hop past.
He probably deserved it.
There will be no conspiracy theories on this one. No anonymous gunmen popping 'Pac, Biggie or J-M-J and disappearing forever. This seems to be a pretty easy case to crack, Holmes. The rumor mill has been redlining since Proof went down, but the Magic 8-Ball is indicating he wasn't merely an innocent bystander.
By all outward appearances -- and judging from the reflections of others -- Proof was a decent guy, at turns humble and gregarious. But things went south somewhere between the beginning of the argument at the Triple C Club and the end.
Maybe it was the percolating frustration of always being the best man and never the Man. Maybe he was just doing the wrong things in the wrong place at the wrong time. Either way, somebody went ahead and finally made Dirty Harry's day. Bing, bang, booming front-page headline: The guy from 8 Mile, killed on 8 Mile.
Hip-hop, it seems, is not without a sense of irony.
Neither am I. Which is why I'd like to close with a quote from one of Proof's own songs. This is taken from the last track on his solo album Searching for Jerry Garcia. The song is called "Kurt Kobain," and it goes a little something like this:
"Maybe I'm ugly inside, but smiling to make it / But I still do this like I love it, even though I thug it / Stars won't grow, who would dream that scars would show? / Minus the MTV videos with Slim, "Up In Smoke," D12 and many shows with Em / It's still me. Dawg, no change for change / It's strange, when it pours it rains / I wish I could take it back, I wish I could take it back / But it's too late."
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene with music features, additional online music listings and show picks. We'll also send special ticket offers and music promotions available only to our Music Newsletter subscribers.