Readers Poll: The Most Underrated Rock Albums Of The '90s

Readers Poll: The Most Underrated Rock Albums Of The '90s

For this week's readers poll, I asked our Facebook and Twitter chums their choices for the most underrated and unsung albums of the '90s.

We all agree on things like Nevermind, Harvest Moon, Mezzanine, The Soft Bulletin, Odelay and OK Computer, but what about albums that fall through the cracks of '90s lore? The ones that don't get teary-eyed blogs written about them, or grand SPIN magazine retrospective covers?

Most of these were no-brainers that I was glad to see mentioned, like The Afghan Whigs' Gentlemen, and more esoteric and adventurous pieces like Kula Shaker's K. Of course, Team Rocks Off snuck a few onto the list. (You're welcome, Live!)

I should have made my case for the Donnas' sophomore album, American Teenage Rock 'n' Roll Machine, recorded before they turned into Turbonegro.

Not all albums from the '90s aren't overrated or underrated. Some things are rated just as they should be. Like The Pixies' Bossanova , Sleater-Kinney's Call the Doctor, or Jawbreaker's Dear You. They are just good, no more no less. Argue amongst yourselves.

Fastball, All the Pain Money Can Buy: You may have only known Fastball for their hit single "The Way" but they turned in a great pop-rock record with 1998's All The Pain..., which featured two other singles that should have been much bigger.

Blind Melon, Soup

Live, Secret Samadhi

The Rentals, Return of the Rentals: If you were into Weezer in the mid-'90s, you surely owned former guitarist Matt Sharp's Rentals work. This one still gets love, a decade and half on.

The Offspring, Ixnay On The Hombre

God Lives Underwater, Life In The So-Called Space Age

White Zombie, La Sexorcisto: Devil Music Vol. 1

Garbage, Version 2.0

Matthew Sweet, Girlfriend

Pulp, Different Class: With Pulp active again -- for now -- many people are rediscovering their catalog, a perfect, glam-inflected take on the Britpop genre. Start with this one.

L7, Bricks Are Heavy

Better Than Ezra, Friction Baby

Bush, Razorblade Suitcase


Local H, Pack Up The Cats: It was a toss-up between this and 1996's As Good As Dead, which I have been a very vocal fan of. You really can't beat the first half of the record, but Cats is our dark horse pick today.

Modest Mouse, This Is a Long Drive for Someone with Nothing to Think About

Tripping Daisy, Jesus Hits Like the Atom Bomb

The Afghan Whigs, Gentlemen

Stone Temple Pilots, Tiny Music...Songs From The Vatican Gift Shop: Fairweather fans will tell you Core and Purple are where it is at for STP, but Tiny Music goes above and beyond those pop lunges and swerved directly into Rolling Stones-style swing.

King's X, Dogman

Peter Gabriel, Us

Quicksand, Slip

Shudder To Think, Pony Express Record: I was suspicious at first, but a spin of Pony set me on the right track, baby. STT is a band whose name you see on most '90s something-something lists but rarely gets love in the mainstream. Don't sleep on Pony.

Buffalo Daughter, New Rock

Dream Theater, Falling into Infinity

Failure, Fantastic Planet

Catherine Wheel, Ferment

Helmet, Meantime

The Prodigy, Music For the Jilted Generation

Kula Shaker, K You know Kula Shaker from the 1996 single "Tattva", and their cover of Deep Purple's "Hush." At a time when modern rock was still very much mourning Seattle, the psych-rock Shaker had their heads full of Indian culture, which was a welcome change. Bands like Cornershop and Brian Jonestown Massacre also satisfied those cravings for fans.

Superdrag, Regretfully Yours

Nada Surf, High/Low

Eels, Beautiful Freak

Follow Rocks Off on Facebook and on Twitter at @HPRocksOff.

Sponsor Content


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >