He's Only a Perv
He's Only a Perv
Voyeur-video dude not a child pornographer
By Richard Connelly
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has formally ruled: Alan Ray Steen is a pervert, he's not a child pornographer.
Steen liked to go to tanning salons and stick a video camera over the cubicle wall to tape women; one day the person he taped turned out to be a girl two weeks shy of her 17th birthday. The video revealed a flash — 1.5 seconds long — on the edge of the frame of the girl's pubic region. As a result, the U.S. Attorney in Odessa prosecuted him for manufacturing child pornography and Steen was convicted and sentenced to 15 years in federal prison.
In an opinion discussing in detail just how lascivious tanning-bed activity might be, the 5th Circuit agreed with Steen's attorney, Brian Wice of Houston, that what was taped was not child pornography, just garden-variety perviness.
"Even Congress could not have intended for this sentence to be applied to 21st Century peeping toms," Wice tells Hair Balls.
The 5th Circuit said the jury was mistaken in ruling that the tape contained "a lascivious exhibition of the genitals."
Also, the whole mise en scène, as they say in film-crit class, just wasn't porny.
The second and third factors consider whether the setting or pose of the depiction is sexually suggestive or unnatural. Traditional settings that meet this standard are beds and bedrooms. A tanning salon is not a sexually suggestive setting, nor are [victim] C.B.'s movements unnatural for someone who is tanning...Under certain circumstances, lying on one's back may be sexually suggestive, but that is not the case when the non-sexual activity being displayed requires one to lie on the back.
C.B., the court ruled, "neither acts coy or willing to engage in sexual activity."
Lastly, the panel examined just what it was that might give Steen a hard-on.
"Even if one assumes Steen was stirred by his voyeuristic pursuits," the court wrote, "there is insufficient evidence to conclude that the image of C.B.'s genitals was designed to elicit a sexual response or whether, perhaps, merely being a voyeur excited Steen."
The case was thrown out. Steen could be charged with the state jail felony of improper videotaping, but then again he's been in a prison since his 2009 conviction.
And not only in prison, but in prison as a manufacturer of child pornography.
"I can't think of anything worse to have on your [file], unless it's 'snitch on the Cali cartel,'" Wice says.
DOING IT DAILY
Theres tons of stuff each day on the Houston Press blogs; youre only getting a taste of it here in the print edition. Head to blogs.houstonpress.com/hairballs (or /rocks or eating or /artattack)
Texas legislators debated forcing women to see sonograms before getting an abortion, but Ohio went one better by having a fetus testify (via heartbeat). So we upped the ante by proposing Texas women be forced to see their fetus's Facebook page. Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee faced more bad national publicity over being a "Boss from Hell," and we reported on an appearance by David Axe, who writes Wired's Danger Room blog.
In honor of the 175th anniversary of Texas declaring its independence, we offered an expert look at the six best archeological sites in the Houston area. Muammar Gadhafi compared Libya to Waco, and why the hell not? And we discovered a canned drink called Milo and imagined what it would be like, based on years of having to listen to and deal with Astros announcer Milo Hamilton.
Gone-but-not-forgetten former Rocket Tracy McGrady led a player revolt in Detroit; March brought with it the annual hatred for Duke and its forever-flopping basketball players, the Coogs and the Owls struggled to end bad seasons, and spring training began.
We checked out the Alley Theatre's latest scorcher, August: Osage County. We paid a visit to Lloyd's Book Shop, which is actually Lloyd's house. We looked back at the month in notable deaths, pinup bombshell Jane Russell in particular. We offered our top picks for the SXSW Film Festival. And we launched "100 Creatives," our ongoing project profiling 100 Houston-area artists.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss Houston Press' biggest stories.
- HBU Says the Feds Are Forcing It to Sin (And These Uber-Conservative Judges Agree)
Thu., Oct. 8, 8:00pm
Fri., Oct. 9, 12:00am
Sun., Oct. 11, 12:00am
Mon., Oct. 12, 12:00am
- KHOU vs. DISH Contract Standoff Still Isn't Over
- College and NFL Football: This Weekend's Best Bets