Teachers Suit Challenges HISD on EVAAS Rating System
HISD is being taken to court in a case filed this week over how it evaluates teachers. Seven teachers are part of the suit, which says a controversial (at least to teachers and their unions) value-added system of rating their classroom work is unconstitutional.
The American Federation of Teachers released a statement that described the suit.
"The federal lawsuit states teachers' due process constitutional rights are being violated because the EVAAS system is not an accurate or reliable indicator of teachers' performance and because "a cloak of secrecy" prevents teachers from verifying or challenging their EVAAS score," the statement said. "The suit also contends teachers' equal protection constitutional rights are being violated because the school district directs and/or pressures school administrators to align teachers' instructional practice scores with their EVAAS scores -- two separate evaluation components -- so those with below-average EVAAS scores receive arbitrary, harsher instructional practice scores. The suit also contends that the standards for acceptable growth are arbitrary, vague and constantly being recalibrated."
According to the Houston Chronicle, the Houston Independent School Board okayed its evaluation system for teachers in 2011.
Teachers have actually gotten pink slips based on these scores, the National Education Police Center explains in a report from 2012.
EVAAS produces "value-added" measures for the same teachers that jump around willy-nilly from large and negative to large and positive from year-to-year when neither the general nature of the students nor the nature of the teaching differs across time. In defense of the EVAAS one could note that this is common to all such systems of attributing students' test scores to teachers' actions so that EVAAS might still lay claim to being "most robust and reliable"--since they are all unreliable and who knows what "robust" means?
Unlike many school districts which have the good sense to use these value-added systems for symbolic purposes only ("Look at us; we are getting tough about quality."), Houston actually fired four teachers (three African-American, one Latina) based on their EVAAS scores.
You can take a look at the suit the teachers filed in federal court, below.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss Houston Press' biggest stories.