Chicken BLT at Natachee's Supper 'n' Punch
Chicken BLT at Natachee's
Katharine Shilcutt was right: Natachee's is getting better and better. I was initially iffy about going back in light of my mediocre burger experience but returned several times after reading her cafe review.
I tried some dishes I had before and found them much improved. I also sampled some entrees for the first time and discovered a new favorite: the Fried Chicken BLT.
Served on two pieces of toasted white bread, the Chicken BLT (or CBLT) is flavorful, filling, and amazingly unsalty. I usually ask for bacon to be removed from my sandwiches due to its propensity to infuse every bit with excessive sodium; however, here it added only added a welcome smokiness. The thick pieces of lightly fried chicken were pure white meat, tender and juicy, and the lettuce and tomato, fresh and crispy. A slathering of chipotle mayonnaise and a hefty slice of Monterrey jack cheese gave the sandwich a nice kick.
The CBLT comes with a choice of potato chips or fries, but I subbed in macaroni and cheese for no charge. As others have observed, Natachee's mac and cheese still needs some work: It can't hold a candle to the M&C at Beaver's or BRC Gastropub in terms of rich (real) cheese flavor and creamy sauce. Nevertheless, I sort of appreciate its slightly gummy, fluorescent-orange quality reminiscent of Kraft. It seems fitting somehow for the price ($1.99) and the setting: plastic diner booths.
Server Danni introduced herself right away and insisted we do the same, so that we were all on a first-name basis throughout the meal. I appreciate the friendly sentiment and the practicality of knowing her name, though there was no way in hell I would be beckoning her from afar ("Danni, could you get me some ketchup, please?"). There are limits even to my brattiness.
But anyway I never had cause to shout, because Danni was amazingly attentive and the food was terrific overall. Good job, Natachee's.
Get the Dining Newsletter
The week's top local food news and events, plus interviews with chefs and restaurant owners, dining tips, and a peek at our print review.