Copycat Recipe: Pappa Geno's Wicked Philly
Holy shit, you guys. I made Pappa Geno's Wicked Philly at home and it was the best thing ever. For real -- this cheese steak is legit. Like MC Hammer legit. Maybe I'll call it the MC Hammer. Or maybe the BV Hammer. I don't know, I'll have to think about it and get back to you.
If you haven't had the Wicked Philly, you must. It's some sort of sick Philly-Chicago cheese steak hybrid loaded with juicy steak, cheese, mayo, and hot giardiniera. Like I said, LEGIT. Also now that I've written legit three times in the matter of a minute I'm going to see how many times I can stick it in this post.
Pappa Geno's original is obviously legit and all (4), but sometimes I don't feel like having a 4,000-calorie sandwich for lunch. My version is by no means a diet dish, yet somehow I feel its a bit lighter...like at least a little. Maybe. I hope. Whatever -- it's definitely smaller and has substantially less oil and mayo. Shut up.
Here's how to make it:
Before you get started on the sandwich, you need to have a few good-quality key ingredients -- the right stuff, if you will (I may or may not be listening to an MC Hammer Pandora station as we speak).
My new friend. I've named him Giac...and I think I love him.
The Right Stuff:
And now for the sandwich!
The original Pappa Geno's wicked Philly, for sake of reference.
Photo by Katharine Shilcutt
BV Hammer Wicked Philly/Chicago Cheese Steak Subs (Yes, I realize the name needs some work). *yields 4 normal-people-sized sandwiches -- if you want to be a fatty and double the recipe go ahead
Heat 1 tbsp oil in a large skillet set over medium-high heat. Add 1 chopped onion and cook until softened, about 5 minutes. Bring heat to low and allow to caramelize. Season with salt and pepper. Remove from pan and set aside.
Meanwhile, pound out slices of steak to ensure thinness.* Brush with oil and season with salt and pepper. *If you are a gypsy-ninja like myself, you may choose to do this with you hands.
Reheat pan to medium-high and add the steak, cooking until browned, about 45-60 seconds per side. Remove from pan and chop into tiny little pieces. Return to pan along with onions and season with garlic and onion powder. Taste and season with salt and pepper as needed. Reduce heat to low.
Cut loaf into sandwich-sized rolls and slice open. Place bread, open-faced down, on top of beef mixture, allowing the steam to soften and warm it.
Remove bread and spread mayonnaise on top, bottom, or if you're crazy, top and bottom.
Divide the beef mixture into 4 and shape to fit roll. Top each with a slice of cheese and cover for 20 seconds to let melt.
Scoop the cheese steak onto the rolls and top with desired amount of hot giardineira. Then be real cool and add some more.
That's it -- not even hard! Now eat it and you'll be all like:
Follow Eating Our Words on Facebook and on Twitter @EatingOurWords
Get the Food & Drink Newsletter
Our weekly guide to Houston dining includes food news and reviews, as well as dining events and interviews with chefs and restaurant owners.