A screenshot of Village in the Shade
It's pretty in the daylight, but after dark is something else. Credit: Screenshot

Overview:

Review of Village in the Shade.

Rating: 8 out of 10

Review based on 13 hours of play on Nintendo Switch 2.

There is a search for the perfect mixture of creepy and cozy in the gaming world. Village in the Shade is not that. Instead, it’s an intense survival horror experience with a little light farming thrown in.

Developed by Nippon Ichi Software, the game is a mutation of their popular survival horror series Yomawari. That franchise is, for my money, the scariest thing in gaming not called Amnesia, cute pixelated chibi graphics be damned. Some of the creepiest things I have ever seen period came out of Yomawari: Midnight Shadows, and Village in the Shade takes that lineage very seriosuly.

You play as a child who disappeared from their village a decade ago and who returns without having aged. The player character is customizable, though genderless, and around ten years old similar to previous Yomawari titles. That’s to be expected. Yomawari has always been dreario-adjacent, and capitalizing on the inherent helplessness of childhood nightmares is a major component of that.

As a cozy farm sim, the game is excellent. Players raise crops, chop down trees, interact with villagers, and all the other staples of games in the Stardew Valley vein. There’s fishing. It’s . . . fine. This one is rhythm-based and better than a lot of other life sims, but I still feel like no one has quite mastered how to make fishing good yet.

Overall, the daily gameplay loop of tasks is rewarding and fun. One great addition is an incredible in-game map that shows the position of every villager as well as all their relevant information (birthday, likes, dislikes, etc.) on one screen. As someone who hates diving through a dozen menus to progress a relationship or sidequest, I do admire how Village in the Shade respects a player’s time with an exceptional user interface.

On the other hand, the game stumbles a bit where the clock is concerned. Half of the fun of a cozy game is sandboxing around, and Village in the Shade is very strict about not letting the player do anything after 6 p.m. It adds to the tension of the weird town’s even weirder rules clearly designed to keep monsters at bay, but it does make the cozy side frustrating.

I hate Rin so much.

Also, making the player character a child seems like a bad decision even if it does fit in with the larger themes of Yomawari. For one, there are no relationship options, which is kind of a cardinal sin in most modern cozy games. For another, everyone in the town seems like a real dick when you remember they are demanding labor out of a grade schooler who is forced to sleep on a stack of cardboard boxes in an empty house. I can’t tell you how many times I said out loud, “this is a kid” when the village treated them badly.

Where the game really shines is when the horror creeps in. It starts with yokai banging on your door in the middle of the night and progresses to the player character running and hiding from screen-filling monstrosities. No punches are pulled. You’ll be stumbling on blood-soaked scenes of carnage pretty early on, and it only gets worse.

Village in the Shade came out three months ago in Asian countries, and some enterprising modders created English language patches ahead of this week’s official North American release. That means eager YouTubers in the cozy game world have already tried it out and a lot of them have not been able to handle the scariness.

I get that. Hell, Nippon Ichi gets that. They offer a special mode that is just the farm sim parts without the horror, though I would take that promise with a grain of salt. Horror games that borrow cozy elements aren’t usually this terrifying.

That said, I think it adds something wonderful to the Yomawari lineage. The cozy parts heighten the dynamics of the horror elements, making them intense and a lot of fun. The farm sim is brighter because the nightmares are darker. Mixing those up and downs in horror is extremely important and murderously difficult, and Village of the Shade does it masterfully.

If you want a spooky farm sim that will tuck you safely into bed, go get Midnight Peaks. If you’d like to have the pants scared off you after a satisfying cozy game loop, Village in the Shade is the perfect place for you.

Village in the Shade is out now on Steam, PlayStation, and Switch. $49.99.

Jef Rouner (not cis, he/him) is a contributing writer who covers politics, pop culture, social justice, video games, and online behavior. He is often a professional annoyance to the ignorant and hurtful.