Five Pencil Skirts That Are Nearly As Nice as J.Crew's $1,800 Version

Let it be said here, pencil skirts are the best. Tall, short, skinny, curvy--there is a pencil skirt that will look gorgeous on you. You can add volume at the hem or the waist to balance curves in other places, or pick something super-slim to keep things sleek. Not only do they suit every body type, but they can be styled to suit almost any occasion--flats and a sweater keep it casual, an oxford shirt and heels are office-appropriate, but paired with a slinky top, sparkly jewelry, and strappy sandals you can easily head out to drinks and dinner.

So, obviously, I am always on the lookout for a great pencil skirt which leads me from my first emotion (love) to my next emotion--shock. Shock, that J.Crew has an $1,800 sequined pencil skirt available on its website. I mean, I know J.Crew has plenty of high-end, high-priced pieces in addition to its more affordable everyday casuals, but something about the "meticulously airbrushed and painted by hand" python-patterned sequined pencil skirt made me gasp out loud. Sure, it's gorgeous, but Sweet Jesus--eighteen hundred dollars?

Naturally, I was tempted but since I like to eat and sleep under a roof and stuff, I had to move on.

It's not that I don't get it--it's a special piece, a one-of-a-kind that can't be replicated ("only a handful exist", after all). But for those of us who can't spend a month (or two) worth of rent on a meticulously airbrushed skirt, let's take a look at some other options.


Thankfully, J.Crew offers pencil skirts much closer to real-people price ranges, starting around $120. And while there are other, expensive "special" sequined pencil skirts (this admiral blue houndstooth for $695 is spectacular), this gold-leaf dotted jacquard ($225) has it all: shine, texture, pattern, and a terrific shape.

Shabby Apple

The ultimate online destination for cute, feminine, vintage-inspired pieces, Shabby Apple is a site I turn to again and again to solve wardrobe crises. They have a strong collection of pencil skirts ranging from cotton casual prints to sequined party options; many have period-inspired details like an extra-high waist or an exaggerated bow. Much love for this '40s style pencil skirt in blue-and-white polka dot ($94).

Rachel Roy at Neiman Marcus

This is a steal--a $270 Rachel Roy pencil skirt on sale for $160. The color is a gorgeous bright fuchsia, sizes 2-12 are available, and the skirt has a "natural rise" and a contrast band that set it apart from the high-waisted options you usually find. Color block this with a bright yellow or orange top, or do as the model does and go fuchsia head-to-toe.

ModCloth is my latest online shopping obsession (that I haven't actually made a purchase from--yet). I love the clothes, though the site's sorting and searching options leave something to be desired, but I found several pencil skirts I love including the 1940s-style Swing Me Around skirt ($59.99). Not for nothing, this is a simple but spectacular pencil skirt. Not exactly office-appropriate, but certainly date-night ready.

Banana Republic

I had to stare long and hard at this Banana Republic skirt but ultimately I decided that I loved it. The belt and the "Cormorant green" color give it a military vibe, and it's a really interesting neutral--different than your usual black or grey or brown. The front, off-seam pockets give it a casual vibe, and the shape (it doesn't taper dramatically at the knee) makes it more wearable for more body types. Work and weekend appropriate--love it.

KEEP THE HOUSTON PRESS FREE... Since we started the Houston Press, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Houston, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Christina Uticone