Actually, remember that time a few years ago, before maverick folk-punker Ani DiFranco went straight and got herself a boyfriend? Surely you must recall all that look at me, I'm bald and tattooed and I like girls! shtick she employed to promote her otherwise awesome playing. Well, cosmetic issues aside, that's exactly the spirit that informs this project. Like DiFranco's best work, it's an onslaught of overwhelming passions unhindered by reason, and you know throughout that the characters will grow out of it all eventually.
There's a temptation to call Lost and Delirious the female Stand By Me, concerned as it is with the agony and ecstasy of adolescent relationships amid the dawning awareness of mortality (except we never saw River Phoenix and Wil Wheaton doing it). For this film's first half-hour, however, a more fitting description might be "The Chocolate War with plaid skirts cleverly substituted for plot." As it's about the trials and tribulations of boarding school, replete with bombastic verse, a charismatic professor, scalding inner torment and wrenching martyrdom, we could also draw an eensy little line over to that Peter Weir film about seizing the day. But let's try to view this story of alienation, suffering and release as some sort of original venture.
Perkins Girls' College is the sort of establishment you'll find only in a mystical Canada, rich with red-brick tradition yet surrounded by lush, verdant forests. The story begins with shy, self-effacing Mary "Mouse" Bradford (Mischa Barton, of the lovely Lawn Dogs) being thrust rather rudely into campus life. Her mother died fairly recently and her father has taken up with a new woman who'd prefer not to have a Mouse in the house. Naturally, this provides Mary with a perfect opportunity to dredge up her repressed resentment, to leap around to bad covers of Violent Femmes classics, to discover new, exciting feelings.
On hand to assist Mary in her coming of age are her senior roommates, brash Paulie (Piper Perabo of Coyote Ugly) and dizzy, sensuous Victoria (Jessica Paré of Stardom). Rather swiftly, however, Mouse starts noticing telltale signs about her friends' alternative vibe, i.e., they sleep together noisily and nude, and just can't seem to keep their hands and mouths off each other. "I know this sounds, like, naive," Mouse confides to us via narration, "but, I mean, I thought they were, like, practicing for boys."
In fact, the crux of the movie hinges on the transition of one of the two young lovers when she discovers her partner may indeed have been "practicing" with her all along. What could have been a happily-ever-after teenage lesbian film called When Tory Met Paulie suddenly runs off its tracks. Victoria, who has a hypersensitive little sister attending Perkins, comes from stiflingly conservative stock. Paulie, on the other hand, makes offhand cracks about her prostitute mother giving her up for adoption. Although the girls are intensely involved, one of them wants balance while the other starves for supernatural swoons of love. Something's gotta give.
What's interesting about Lost and Delirious is that it plays out more like an advice column than a dramatic narrative, with all relevant psychological elements on display as in some case study. Sure, Paulie is as prone to spurting lines from Macbeth at inopportune moments as Victoria is likely to wander off weeping in slow motion, but the obviousness of the proceedings prompts chuckles at moments that should be heart-rending. The movie is beautiful to look at, as are the girls, but it takes its clunky message so seriously that it often verges on silliness.
It's pretty much a given that abuse and neglect lead to insolent and self-destructive behavior, so it comes as no surprise when the movie shifts its focus to Paulie's overt sexuality and strident machismo. But the bigger twist comes when Mary casually defines her roommate as a lesbian, and Paulie recoils in denial. Announcing that she's not, that she's simply in love with the ultra- feminine, voluptuous Victoria, one starts to wonder how far hunger for a nurturing mother can transport a soul.
Although there's loads of wonderful acting from all three leads, Pool is a little heavy-handed in her delivery, which detracts from the performances. We slip between bathos and fury and voyeurism so often that much of it starts to feel stilted. Thank goodness Graham Greene steps in as a friendly greenskeeper with a fumbling wit; when asked by Mary how much it matters what other people think, he quips, "I suppose that depends on how much they're payin' ya." On that note, let's hope we can keep paying Pool to inspire and confound us, but let's also hope she grants us access beyond the obvious.