Beck Hansen's 1994 breakthrough lo-fi single "Loser" begged an interesting question: one-hit wonder, or new Dylan? Odelay, Beck's first major-label release since his Mellow Gold debut, answers the question nicely. The answer is neither. Hits number two and three are already accounted for with "Devil's Haircut" and "Where It's At," surely to be followed in short order with any number of tracks off this densely packed disc. As for the Dylan thing, well, Dylan at his most surreally non-literal was never so surreally non-literal as Beck's "Silver foxes lookin' for romance / In the chainsmoke Kansas flashdance ass pants" (from "Hotwax"). And what the hell could it possibly mean when Beck spends his lead track intoning, "I got a devil's haircut in my mind"?
A whole bunch of nothing, if you ask me, but that doesn't mean Beck does not sound great saying it. Part of that sleight of hand is due to the manchild's voice: a cannonball of offhand gravity that lends weight to the slightest pop-culture ephemera. And part of it is due to production by the Dust Brothers -- the audio wizards responsible for the Beastie Boys' Paul's Boutique. What the brothers have done is unhinge Beck from his basement-tape limitations and let him roam free in a po-mo hodgepodge of sound that's the perfect mirror for his disjointed lyrical referents. There's some post-"Loser" slide guitar work, some Beastie-ish organ lines, some frighteningly authentic country-tonk empathy and enough tasteful sampling to keep trivia buffs happy for months. All anchored -- if that word can be applied to such sonic free-float -- on a white-boy hip-hop sensibility whose exemplars remain the Beastie Boys.
But if the Beasties are still kings of this domain, Beck is their crown prince in waiting. And it's Beck, more than the Beasties, whose trek from a New York anti-folk fixation on acoustic blues to the Los Angeles-drenched freestyle of Odelay makes the best case for hip-hop as our truest urban folk music. (****)
-- Brad Tyer
After toeing basically the same hard, speedy and intricate line for more than a decade, Metallica was in a unique -- if unenviable -- position when assembling the tunes for Load. Did they continue preaching to the converted (who, by the way, have sent the band's last few releases past platinum), or did they continue taking their bruising sound in the more refined, song-centric direction they'd been fiddling with since 1988's ... And Justice for All?
Five years after the release of Metallica, it seems that the band has gone with the latter, and, as you might expect, the results are mixed. Load is sometimes brilliant, but other times it's tarnished with the creeping, corrosive compound of commercialism and an excessive eagerness to please. Even so, undeniable links to past glories crop up in enough places to assure us that Metallica has not gone irreversibly astray.
Load begins strongly with "Until It Sleeps" and "King Nothing," their grandiose choruses and multiple transitions an obvious extension of Metallica's attempts to refine and contain the group's bullish conceits for the radio. Lyrically, James Hetfield is as menacing and punishing as you would expect, but his message tends to meander as he searches for unnecessary vocal nuance, rather than just belting it out as he should. More direct and unhampered by self-consciousness are the CD's stinging guitars, which have a visceral razor-sharp intrusiveness that harks back to ... And Justice for All and its monumentally forthright sound, courtesy of producer Bob Rock. And how about that cover, which features a photo by controversial artist Andres Serrano of Serrano's semen mixed with cow's blood and squished between two plates of glass. Repugnant or beautiful? Calculated compromise or creative victory? Better to let the kids decide. (*** 1/2)
-- Greg Barr
Metallica performs at Lollapalooza Thursday, July 25, at Fort Dallas, Dallas.
Bringing Down the Horse
When you're the son of the most influential songwriter of the 20th century, deciding to go into the family business can be both a quick blessing and a deadly curse. For Jakob Dylan, leader of the Wallflowers, being born with a high-powered surname surely made for an easier entrance into record company offices. But once through the door, the expectations to be a chip off the old block had to be nearly impossible to realize. And the young Dylan isn't making it any easier for himself. Understandably reluctant to accept notoriety he hasn't earned, Jakob keeps his famous relationship quiet (the Wallflowers' bio doesn't even mention dad), even though the added notice couldn't have hurt. And of all the musical styles he could have plied -- from punk to techno to R&B -- Jakob chose the mythic folk-rock Americana that his pop pretty much invented.