Environment

Valero Was the Likely Source of the Mystery Stink in Manchester During Harvey

It's becoming increasingly clear where that funky smell that popped up in Manchester in the middle of Harvey actually came from.
It's becoming increasingly clear where that funky smell that popped up in Manchester in the middle of Harvey actually came from. Photo by Doogie Roux
As the city continues to sort itself out in the wake of Hurricane Harvey, it's becoming increasingly clear — at least to anyone who hadn't already figured it out — where the "mystery stench" that enveloped Manchester and much of the east side of Houston in the middle of the hurricane actually came from.

The Valero refinery has been looked at from early on as the most likely culprit, since the massive refinery hugs Manchester's fence line, and, all things considered, the odds seem pretty high that Valero was one of the main sources of benzene and a slew of volatile organic compounds that were released into the air when rain sank the roofs of storage tanks on the property during Harvey, allowing all kinds of chemicals into the air that people are not supposed to inhale.

Valero acknowledged in a statement issued shortly after the accidental chemical release that something had gone wrong. But the company downplayed it, contending that officials "found no detectable levels of emissions in the community.”

While Valero isn't the only refinery or plant in the area, it is the closest by far, which makes the contention that there were no detectable emissions particularly questionable.


Juan Parras, the founder of Texas Environmental Advocacy Services, went through Manchester in the middle of Harvey and reported that the whole place smelled like a gas stove. "I was afraid to even light a match; I kept thinking everything would burst into flames if I did," Parras said.

We already knew that Valero and the other area plants and refineries along the Houston Ship Channel collectively released thousands of tons of pollutants into the air either during the hurricane or immediately after, but the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality reports apparently did not cover everything that escaped.

How do we know this? Because the federal Environmental Protection Agency's enforcement division recently swept in and demanded that records and maintenance histories regarding the storage tanks that leaked during the hurricane be handed over, demands that Valero is required to respond to.

The push for these records comes as EPA officials have also let it be known they believe Valero "significantly underestimated" the amount of benzene and other harmful compounds that leaked out of the refinery during the torrential downpours from Harvey.

Valero's initial estimates for the release during Harvey were fairly modest, with just over six pounds of benzene allegedly let loose in the atmosphere and about 3,350 pounds of unspecified substances released. However, EPA officials say they expect to adjust the amounts reported "significantly" once they have completed their investigation of the release.

While both the EPA and TCEQ turned off their air monitors in advance of the hurricane, the EPA was back in Houston neighborhoods once the storm had passed with its Trace Atmospheric Gas Analyzer, a lab bus that takes samples and measures air quality directly. Using the TAGA bus, EPA officials concluded that the probable source of benzene and volatile organic compound readings in and around Manchester was the roof failure and spill from a light crude storage tank at the Valero Houston Refinery during Harvey, according to a release.

Until the EPA finishes investigating, the jury is out on how much Valero ultimately released, but based on the amount of benzene traced in the air after the hurricane, we're betting it won't be a small amount.

Meanwhile, Valero has been back up and running since shortly after the storm.
KEEP THE HOUSTON PRESS FREE... Since we started the Houston Press, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Houston, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Dianna Wray is a nationally award-winning journalist. Born and raised in Houston, she writes about everything from NASA to oil to horse races.
Contact: Dianna Wray