With St. Paddy's Day just around the corner, last week I was looking for the perfect recipe to pay homage to my small bit of Irish heritage. I have a strong aversion to traditional Irish dishes like corned beef, soda bread and pretty much anything with cabbage, so I needed something different. And I was cooking for one, so I was looking for a recipe with that comfort food appeal that wouldn't cause me to gain 10 pounds from after eating leftovers a couple nights.
Shepherd's pie seemed to fit the bill nicely. With a few simple changes, it can be made more figure-friendly. For a lighter alternative that still feels like comfort food, I combined a super-healthy recipe found here with a full-on version found here, and did a bit of improvising. Now I could have my pie and drink an extra Guinness too.
For the filling, I used carrots, peas, onions, Italian seasoning and ground turkey breast. You could certainly keep the traditional ground lamb as it is lean, but I had turkey on hand so that's what I went with. I followed the beginning instructions for the healthy recipe, cooking the meat and veggies (swapping the mushrooms for peas) up in a bit of olive oil. I didn't have fresh herbs on hand so improvised with a dried Italian seasoning mix and minced garlic. I added in the flour and cooked for a few more minutes before deglazing with my secret ingredient, a bottle of stout. Follow this up with a tablespoon of tomato paste and you will have just created the most delicious, savory, yet slightly sweet, deeply flavored shepherd's pie sauce ever.
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to the mission of the Houston Press. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Houston’s stories with no paywalls.
Support Our Journalism
For the all-important mashed potato topping, I made my potatoes simply, with russet potatoes, skim milk, a few tablespoons of butter, salt and pepper. This is not a place to load up on the fat; I promise you won't miss the cream or extra butter, as there is enough flavor in the mixture beneath. I topped the potatoes with a sprinkling of low-fat cheddar (don't use fat-free, it won't melt properly).
I cooked the dish in individual ramekins so each serving would have perfectly crusty edges -- also, because they're cute -- and baked at 350 degrees for about a half hour (remove when the potatoes and cheese form a slightly golden, bubbly crust of Irish awesomeness).