AJ Armstrong, who was 16 when his parents were murdered, has maintained his innocence since the crime occurred in 2016. Credit: Screenshot

A decade after Dawn and Antonio Armstrong Sr. were murdered in their southwest Houston home, their son who was convicted of the crime and sentenced to life in prison could be tried again, making it the fourth time his case has gone before a Harris County jury. 

AJ Armstrong, who was 16 years old in 2016 when his parents were fatally shot in their bed, will go back before a Harris County judge on Tuesday, October 27. His attorney Rick DeToto says heโ€™ll claim that prosecutors failed to disclose information about a misconduct complaint against a key forensic witness in Armstrongโ€™s 2023 trial. 

โ€œGoing on 10 years now, we have been fighting for AJ,โ€ DeToto said in an email to the Houston Press. โ€œDuring the three trials, there was hidden evidence, lost evidence and the miracle discovery of new evidence days before the third trial.โ€

Itโ€™s up to Judge Kelli Johnson in Harris Countyโ€™s 178th District Court to determine whether the claims warrant a new trial. 

Juries in the first two trials, in 2019 and 2022, couldnโ€™t agree on Armstrongโ€™s guilt or innocence, resulting in mistrials. The Harris County DAโ€™s office opted to try Armstrong again and he was convicted of murder in 2023, sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 40 years of incarceration. He has most recently been housed in general population at the French Robertson Unit in Abilene but is currently at the Harris County Jail awaiting Tuesdayโ€™s hearing.  

The case has received considerable media attention due to Armstrongโ€™s age at the time the crime occurred and the fact that his late father was a former NFL linebacker, gym owner and associate pastor at Spirit of Life Church. 

In the early morning hours of July 29, 2016, Armstrong called 911 and said a masked man entered his home and shot his parents. About seven minutes into the call, the teen can be heard saying, โ€œItโ€™s all my fault.โ€ Defense attorneys maintain that wasnโ€™t a confession but that Armstrong felt he should have done more to prevent the attack. Armstrong maintained his innocence throughout the court proceedings. 

The Houston Police Department arrested the teen within hours of the shootings. Authorities said they found no sign of a struggle or forced entry into the home. Prosecutors suggested that Armstrong held a pillow over the faces of his mother and father and shot them both with a gun that was already in the home.  

Jurors heard evidence that Armstrongโ€™s relationship with his parents was strained because the teen was failing classes in school, doing drugs and lying.  

Armstrongโ€™s younger sister Kayra, who was 12 years old at the time, was home sleeping when the shootings occurred. An older half-brother Josh lived nearby but authorities say he was not present during the shootings. KPRC reported that medical records disclosed after the murders show that Josh was diagnosed with schizophrenia and was “hallucinating, hearing voices, had a plan to sacrifice an animal, and had homicidal ideations.”

Armstrong has not offered a theory as to who pulled the trigger that night but has criticized investigators for focusing solely on him. โ€œIt put us in a situation where we donโ€™t have anything, and weโ€™re probably going to have to live the rest of our lives not knowing what happened to my parents,โ€ he said in a 2023 interview. โ€œThatโ€™s unfortunate, but itโ€™s the situation the Houston Police Department and the DAโ€™s office put us in.โ€ 

AJ Armstrong is pictured in a December 2023 interview with KPRC after he was convicted of murdering his parents at their Bellaire home. Credit: Screenshot

In the third trial, when Armstrong was convicted, prosecutors presented a T-shirt that the teen was wearing on the night of the murder. According to court testimony, the shirt was tested in 2016 by the Houston Forensic Science Center and found to have no DNA evidence. Seven years later, during the 2023 trial, forensic investigator Celestina Rossi testified for the state, claiming two specks of blood matched to Antonio Armstrong Sr. were on the shirt. 

Armstrong’s attorneys argue that prosecutors should have disclosed a complaint against Rossi submitted to the Texas Forensic Science Commission in 2019. The complaint alleged misconduct in another case and was later dismissed, but Armstrongโ€™s attorneys say the information was pertinent to Armstrongโ€™s case because it could potentially undermine the witnessโ€™ credibility. 

The DAโ€™s office has said the dismissed complaint against Rossi was irrelevant and inadmissible, and they had strong evidence against Armstrong even without Rossiโ€™s testimony. A spokesman for the DAโ€™s office did not respond to requests for comment this week. 

DeToto has said in previous interviews that the DAโ€™s office tried to block the hearing for a new trial but the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals denied the request last month, saying a new trial is not guaranteed but the hearing can proceed. 

While it may appear that the DAโ€™s office is desperate to keep Armstrong in prison, itโ€™s worth noting that current District Attorney Sean Teare was elected in November 2024 and his administration didnโ€™t prosecute Armstrong in any of his previous trials. 

KPRC reported that multiple HPD officers who testified during the trials said they saw no blood on Armstrong when he was arrested. DeToto has said that the dried blood that appeared after seven years is likely the result of cross-contamination.ย 

Armstrong sued the Houston Police Department, claiming the evidence was โ€œplanted by, or in conspiracy with, one or more persons at the HPD in order to try and convict Armstrong of capital murder and to taint his reputation in the mind of the public.”

After his parentsโ€™ deaths, Armstrong married his high school sweetheart, Kate Ober, and she had a baby, Hendrix, in November 2020. Ober filed for divorce in May 2025, saying she still loves her husband but โ€œlife is complicated.โ€ Armstrong has spoken publicly about developing a relationship with God and getting involved in prison ministry. 

A Facebook group, Justice for AJ Armstrong, has 2,700 followers, some of whom are raising money to โ€œhelp AJ prepare for his new trial hearing.โ€ 

In a 55-minute interview with KPRC in December 2023, Armstrong claimed that he was falsely accused and convicted and that he did not kill his parents. 

โ€œThereโ€™s no way, ever, in a million years I would have imagined being here, but here I am,โ€ he said through a glass window at the Abilene prison. โ€œItโ€™s just about taking it one day at a time. The appeal process can be a slow process, but at the end of the day I know Iโ€™m going to walk out of here. This isnโ€™t how my story ends.โ€

DeToto said in an email Thursday that his client remains hopeful. โ€œAJ is grateful for the hearing on the motion for a new trial and the defense looks forward to presenting witnesses alleging, once again, a failure to disclose evidence,โ€ DeToto said. 

Staff writer April Towery covers news for the Houston Press. A native Texan, she studied journalism at Texas A&M University and has covered Texas news for more than 25 years. She won the 2025 Association...