State Board of Education member-elect Michelle Palmer addressed the Bayou Blue Democrats at a November 11 meeting. Credit: April Towery

Michelle Palmer, a longtime teacher and public education advocate, lost two bids for the State Board of Education in 2020 and 2022. She didnโ€™t give up her dream of serving long hours as an unpaid volunteer on the powerful panel, and on November 3, she won. 

Texan students actually get to claim the victory, says Palmer, who teaches U.S. history and government to 11th and 12th graders at Aldine ISD. She previously worked for Houston ISD but resigned in 2019 prior to the state takeover. 

Palmer, 56, is a product of Texas public schools and has been a teacher since 2009. She says sheโ€™s been concerned for a long time about the Christian nationalist political movement that has elected officials infusing Bible texts into required reading lists, teaching Moses and Abraham as historical figures, and altering history books to espouse Islamophobic rhetoric, trivialize the horrors of American slavery and amplify Christianity as the only faith worth studying. 

โ€œThe students of Texas deserve better,โ€ she said in a phone interview with the Houston Press last week. โ€œThis is the most diverse state in the United States, and every single one of my students and all the students in Texas deserve to have a curriculum that doesnโ€™t call them terrorists. They deserve to have truth in curriculum. They deserve to have their stories being told. Every group of people in this country helped to make Texas what it is.โ€

So her first priority when sheโ€™s sworn into office in January is to undo controversial curriculum rewrites that were approved earlier this year. She wonโ€™t have to do it alone. 

Palmer will be joined in Austin by new fellow Democrat board members Thomas Ray Garcia, Correta Mallet-Fontenot, Allison Bush and Dana Van de Walker. The November 3 State Board of Education elections represent a flip from what was once an 11-4 GOP majority to an 8-7 Democratic advantage. Democrat Tiffany Clark was re-elected to her District 13 seat, and two other Democrats remain on the Board. 

Van de Walker won her District 8 seat by 569 votes, within the margin for her Republican opponent, incumbent Audrey Young, to request a recount. While Young hasnโ€™t conceded the race, she also did not file the recount paperwork by Fridayโ€™s deadline. 

Palmer anticipates that it wonโ€™t be smooth sailing even though her party is now in the majority. Republican incumbent Board member Julie Pickren, who participated in the January 6 insurrection and is considered by many critics to be one of the most extreme among the Christian nationalists, defeated Democratic challenger Tiffany Perkinz, a Port Neches English teacher, and will stay on the Board for another four-year term. 

Perkinz was undeterred by her loss. She celebrated the blue flip by getting a tattoo of Texas bluebonnets on her left arm and vowed to continue making good trouble at the Board meetings in Austin. 

The flip is a big deal because it comes months after the board fought over curriculum changes, sometimes until the wee hours of the morning, and heard hundreds of hours of public testimony from teachers, students and other stakeholders, most of whom were concerned that history was being altered and students were being โ€œindoctrinatedโ€ with Christian teachings that they say exclude students of other faiths and those who practice no faith. 

Public education advocates have, for months, held news conferences and taken legal action against state laws that they say stifle religious freedom and violate the Texas Constitutionโ€™s mandate for the separation of church and state. 

During the TEKS overhaul, residents told the Press that K-12 schools should be places where children feel accepted and safe, and can learn about all aspects of history, even the ones that make them uncomfortable. Some Christian families and faith leaders joined lawsuits against the state mandate that Ten Commandments posters be displayed in every public school classroom, as long as theyโ€™re donated. 

The Ten Commandments matter wasnโ€™t an SBOE decision โ€” that came from the Legislature โ€” but it likely wonโ€™t be enforced now that most of the politicians who pushed for it were ousted from their seats in the midterm election. 

New State Board of Education members will be sworn in on January 25 prior to a Board meeting in Austin. Gov.-Elect Gina Hinojosa will appoint the Board chair. 

The curriculum rewrites adopted earlier this year donโ€™t become effective until 2030, so another overhaul is feasible, Palmer says. 

โ€œWhether we can do that at the January meeting, weโ€™re trying to figure that out,โ€ she says. โ€œIt will definitely be happening in 2027. Different people want different things.โ€ 

A curriculum overhaul could involve more than just adding references to slavery and Islamic culture and removing excessive teachings from the Bible, Palmer explained. A few years ago, the SBOE authorized the reordering of social studies lessons so theyโ€™re taught chronologically, which Palmer says โ€œgoes against all pedagogy.โ€

โ€œI completely disagree with it,โ€ she says. โ€œAn 8-year-old should not be learning about ancient history. They should be learning about their community. I want to undo that, which means the standards have to start over completely. Not everybody on the Democratic side is seeing it that way because it would take longer. They want to see us take out the most offensive stuff.โ€

โ€œIf thatโ€™s the way the majority of the Democrats feel, I will try to talk them out of it, but I will accept it if I absolutely must. I donโ€™t think itโ€™s whatโ€™s best for the kids of Texas, and I think it will cause a lot of problems for a very long time,โ€ she added. 

The Democrats on the SBOE are supported by Houston American Federation of Teachers president Jackie Anderson, who said last week that a curriculum overhaul should be a priority. 

โ€œThey need to put back all of the things that have been removed unfairly,โ€ she said. โ€œTexas history is Texas history, and it should not be whitewashed. Their priority should be to restore the curriculum and make sure the truth is taught to our children.โ€ 

Teach the Truth

โ€œTeach the truthโ€ is a mantra that officials at the Austin-based nonprofit Texas Freedom Network have been shouting for years. The agency was formed in 1995 to serve as a watchdog for the SBOE. Director Felicia Martin said in a statement last week that Texas families have become increasingly aware of the Boardโ€™s power to set curriculum and have expressed vociferous opposition to the recent alterations. 

โ€œThe Republican Board didnโ€™t listen, but as always, voters got the final say,โ€ Martin said. โ€œWe are fed up with political ideologies being put over the education of our kids, and families have made that mandate quite clear.โ€ 

In June, the organization held a funeral for religious freedom on the grounds of the state Capitol while the Board was considering updates to the social studies curriculum and mandatory reading lists for each grade. In the months leading up to the election, Texas Freedom Network targeted tens of thousands of low-propensity voters with mailers, phone calls and text messages. 

The State Board of Education has had a Republican majority since 1994. The effort to infuse Christianity into public school classrooms has come in waves over the years, but has ramped up recently as some Board members, backed by Christian nationalist PACs for the purpose of โ€œChristianizingโ€ public education, have been relentless in their efforts. 

Controversial hearings over science curriculum related to creation versus evolution date back to the late 1990s and early 2000s when Don McLeroy, a Bryan dentist, served as a trustee for 13 years and was appointed Board chair by then-Gov. Rick Perry in 2007.

A 2012 documentary, The Revisionaries, exposes the power of the Texas board. As the biggest purchasers of textbooks in the United States, Texas dictates the materials purchased by school districts across the country, Martin says. โ€œWhatever Texas decides that they want or do not want in textbooks, thatโ€™s what the publishers end up printing, and that ends up being the textbook for most of America.โ€

After the McLeroy era, the state legislature attempted to rein in the SBOE, โ€œkind of as punishment, even though they were also Republicans,โ€ Palmer says. โ€œThey were like, you are going too far. A saner State Board of Education was elected. Since the Tea Party, we have gone back in the direction of Christian nationalism.โ€ 

Texas Freedom Network political director Rocรญo Fierro-Pรฉrez explained that the State Board of Education has been incredibly thorough in its curriculum rewrites, โ€œgoing line by line and choosing what words go into the textbooks.โ€ 

โ€œThe board has become more politically divisive,โ€ she says. โ€œThereโ€™s been this push to go far, far right. Thereโ€™s a sense that if youโ€™re not MAGA or a Christian nationalist, youโ€™re not really a Republican. That is so concerning. That is making its way into our classrooms. People see these ads on TV, and they believe them because there is no fact-checking. Itโ€™s like, wait a minute, thatโ€™s not the version of Christianity that I believe. Itโ€™s a personal thing that really belongs in the home or at Sunday school, not in public schools.โ€

Fierro-Pรฉrez says public schools have become a โ€œproxy fight over who gets to define American identity, and theyโ€™re embedding religion into that.โ€ 

โ€œIf they were to teach religion and talk about it in an objective and historical way, thatโ€™s definitely something that kids would benefit from and would prepare them for the real world,โ€ she said. โ€œWhatโ€™s happening more and more now is youโ€™re getting people who are more extreme and are pushing an ideology. Theyโ€™re pushing a narrative to shift culture and theyโ€™re not really concerned about the curriculum and quality education that is based on facts and truth. Thatโ€™s what is so dangerous about politicians who are weaponizing religion.โ€ 

โ€œItโ€™s political theater, and theyโ€™re playing with peopleโ€™s lives,โ€ she added. 

Newly elected State Board of Education member Michelle Palmer, center, poses with Texas Democratic Party Chair Kendall Scudder and Lt. Gov.-Elect Vikki Goodwin. Credit: April Towery

All of the Democratic challengers who are now joining the Board bring education experience, including Van de Walker, a community college administrator and former teacher. Garcia, a professor at South Texas College in the Rio Grande Valley and a former high school teacher, has said that he supports fully funding public schools and rejects the school voucher program. 

Those are legislative matters, not to be decided by the SBOE, but itโ€™s relevant for trustees to speak out about issues they donโ€™t control so residents have peace of mind on how they will generally vote on the items that are under their purview, Palmer says. The Board members are independently elected but they follow guidance from the state. 

โ€œThe state legislature can pass bills telling us what to do,โ€ Palmer says. โ€œRemember when there was a big deal about Florida passing the โ€˜donโ€™t say gayโ€™ bill? Texas has had that for years. Teachers in the classroom are not allowed to teach gay civil rights. [State legislators] are the ones who say we canโ€™t have comprehensive sex education.โ€ 

โ€œ[New Lt. Gov.] Vikki Goodwin is going to be wrangling cats trying to get the Senate to agree on vouchers,โ€ Palmer added. โ€œGina Hinojosa seems to be doing some things with executive orders, so weโ€™ll see what can happen in that way.โ€

The blue wave extended well beyond the SBOE, and the Texas House also flipped to a Democratic majority. New bills have already been filed to repeal the school voucher program, raise the per-student public school allotment, change school funding from attendance-based to enrollment-based and increase Teacher Retirement System benefits. 

Christian Nationalismย 

A common refrain among conservatives this election cycle was that thereโ€™s nothing wrong with prayer in schools and Christian educators and school board members shouldnโ€™t be ashamed of their faith. 

But thatโ€™s not what Christian nationalism is, critics argue. 

The Texas Freedom Network launched a website last month to educate voters on the topic, which they maintain is a political movement intended to infiltrate all levels of government. 

According to the website, Christian nationalism isnโ€™t about faith or religious freedom; itโ€™s about power and control. Christian organizations, including the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty and the National Council of Churches, reject Christian nationalism as a weaponized distortion of their beliefs.

โ€œAdherents are deeply hostile to public education and seek to co-opt public schools to promote Christian values as they see them,โ€ the website states. โ€œThey reject womenโ€™s equality, call for repealing the 19th Amendment, and want to criminalize same-sex relationships. Doug Wilson, the self-proclaimed Christian nationalist pastor of President Trumpโ€™s Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, has even defended slavery.โ€

Palmer says sheโ€™s well aware that sheโ€™ll be coming into an established board with โ€œextreme far-rightโ€ members who may not be receptive to her progressive ideas. 

โ€œIt will definitely be a challenge,โ€ she says, noting that one Republican trustee has already reached out and said she was receptive to revamping the social studies curriculum. That being said, โ€œthere are people on the board that I doubt I will ever agree with on much of anything,โ€ Palmer says. โ€œAnyone whoโ€™s not a Christian nationalist, I think I can find a lot of common ground with. We just want whatโ€™s best for the students and for everyone who helped build this country to be seen in the standards.โ€ 

Michelle Palmer celebrated her win with supporters at a November 7 victory party. Credit: April Towery

Palmer was supported during her campaign by the Harris County Democratic Party, Houston Progressive Caucus and Houston Democracy Project founder Neil Aquino, who attended Palmerโ€™s November 7 victory party at Chavez Mexican Cafe. 

โ€œI canโ€™t overstate the time and effort Michelle has put in for nearly a decade now standing up for good education in Texas and democracy,โ€ Aquino says. โ€œItโ€™s hard to imagine someone more deserving of their win. Michelle is one of us in the best sense of the term. She has a full commitment not just to Texas students and teachers, but to the power each of us has to fight back and make stuff better no matter the issue.โ€

Palmer says she expects criticism from those who think she interjects her personal beliefs into history and government lessons in the classroom. She doesnโ€™t, she says. 

โ€œI mostly teach my courses through research projects. Theyโ€™re doing presentations and analyzing primary documents,โ€ she says. โ€œYou learn how the government works through that. I donโ€™t need to infuse my own politics into that. Pretty much every Friday, unless Iโ€™m giving a test, is current events day. The kids are talking about their political views and I just let them talk.โ€

โ€œItโ€™s a very student-centered way to teach,โ€ she added. โ€œThey can take it in whatever direction they want. In my opinion, thatโ€™s the best way to teach. I think itโ€™s wrong to infuse my politics in class.โ€ 

Palmer says she doesnโ€™t think the Texas blue wave occurred solely because of a single issue. Many voters are dissatisfied with the current federal immigration policy. Some donโ€™t like data centers or want to be able to use THC products with impunity. The common denominator, however, is dissatisfaction with the status quo, she says. 

โ€œItโ€™s because of what Texas has been doing to Texas education,โ€ she says. โ€œItโ€™s about affordability, and that does go back to Trump and his war in Iran. Itโ€™s also all of the culture war stuff. I think people are tired of it.โ€

For people who say they donโ€™t care whatโ€™s being taught in public schools because they donโ€™t have school-age children, Palmerโ€™s response is twofold. 

โ€œDo you want the Texas economy to stay robust?โ€ she says. โ€œIf so, then we need people who are educated. And do you want the people who take care of you when youโ€™re older to have critical thinking skills and be intelligent enough to do their job effectively to keep you alive? That depends on public education in the state of Texas.โ€ 

Staff writer April Towery covers news for the Houston Press. A native Texan, she studied journalism at Texas A&M University and has covered Texas news for more than 25 years. She won the 2025 Association...