James Talarico speaks during an October campaign event at the University of Houston. Credit: Jack Gorman

“Why does it seem like most Democrats hate Christians?” begins a social media post that became a viral meme. 

One response from “AnnieW1956” sums it up: “Democrats don’t hate Christians. Most are Christians themselves. What they hate are people who spew Bible verses on Sunday, deport humans on Monday, shoot bystanders on Tuesday, tax the poor on Wednesday, take food from children on Thursday, think it’s OK for children to die in schools by a shooter on Friday, take healthcare from the sick on Saturday, and then start spewing Bible verses again on Sunday.”  

The far-right Republicans, on the other hand, say they’re concerned that the left has become overrun with communists who will be soft on crime, embrace gender transition for children and sink the country deeper into debt to pay for social services. 

Both candidates running for the Texas-based U.S. Senate seat on November 3 — Ken Paxton and James Talarico — are white male elected officials who claim Christianity, although the way they practice their faith couldn’t be more different. 

Republican Paxton, who currently serves as the Texas attorney general, has a widely circulated mugshot from when he surrendered at the Collin County Jail in 2015 on two felony counts of first-degree securities fraud and one count of failing to register as an investment adviser. 

However, Paxton has never been convicted of a crime. He was impeached for corruption and abuse of office by members of the Republican-led Texas House in 2023, although he was later acquitted by the Senate. His wife, a state senator, is divorcing him on “biblical grounds,” a reference to adultery, but has encouraged her supporters to vote for the GOP, “even when you’re mad at them.” 

Democrat Talarico, a popular Austin-based state representative, doesn’t have a rap sheet but he’s made some public statements regarding gender identity that are dealbreakers for most conservatives and some moderates. Critics say his support of transgender youth is a feel-good message to score votes, and it’s difficult to determine what he actually believes. 

Talarico earned a master of arts in theological divinity from Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary last year and is continuing his education to pursue a master of divinity. 

He’s the grandson of a Baptist preacher, attends St. Andrew’s Presbyterian Church in North Austin and his progressive approach appeals to Muslims, Jews and Christians of multiple denominations. He organized “Faithful Texans for Talarico” last year, which includes representatives from several religious backgrounds. 

And yet it’s Paxton who’s been billed as the Christian candidate on the ticket. 

No one knows what church, if any, Paxton regularly attends, just that he once claimed membership at Prestonwood Baptist in Collin County. He formed a coalition of 27 evangelical pastors from across Texas earlier this year, and the group has met with him at least once to pray for the Senate campaign. 

Christian Collins, a conservative activist and organizer with the late Charlie Kirk’s Turning Point USA, shared a photo of pastors praying for Paxton on social media this week with the caption: “Pastors who hold an Orthodox Christian worldview continue to coalesce around Ken Paxton because he has always stood for religious liberty, pro-life values, securing our southern border, fighting crime and stopping the transitioning of children. Texas values.” 

Shannon Holzer, a professor of government at Houston Christian University, says the Paxton appeal is that people know what he believes, even if his behavior doesn’t always align with Christian values, and therefore they have a reasonable expectation that, if elected to Congress, he’ll support abortion bans and mandates for Christian literature in public schools. 

“Most people are well aware that nobody’s perfect, so you support people who are more aligned with what you believe. It would take something very egregious for either party to change sides,” Holzer says. “If somebody does something that you find offensive, typically what would happen is you’d just abstain from voting rather than vote for the other party.”

Wil Jeudy, founder of the Secular Houston organization that advocates for separation of church and state, says he’s baffled that Republicans have deemed Paxton the Christian candidate. Jeudy says he’s supporting Talarico because he trusts him. 

“He has a track record in the Texas Legislature of having these Christian beliefs and speaking on them, but he pushes back on Christian nationalism in the most perfect way,” Jeudy says. “He’s done it consistently, advocating for public education and pushing back on the Ten Commandments bill. There’s nothing about him that would make us think that once he gets in the Senate, he’s going to flip.”

And not that it matters to Jeudy, who describes himself as a secular humanist, but “any objective measure puts Talarico as the absolute better example of a Christian than Paxton.”

Jeudy says that radical Christian nationalists create a “patina of goodness around gross people.”

“Without that patina of goodness, which Christian nationalism affords, it’s an empty barrel and it’s a lot harder to vote for this person or advocate for this person or be proud of this person,” Jeudy says. “If you have the patina of goodness around him, it makes it palatable to vote for Paxton.”

Behavior and Statements

Rocío Fierro-Pérez is the political director for the Austin-based Texas Freedom Network, an agency that formed 31 years ago to serve as a watchdog for the State Board of Education. She says Texans aren’t necessarily becoming more interested in Christianity, but there has been a rise in the Christian nationalist political movement that wants “government to affirm and promote a particular version of Christianity through public institutions like public schools.” 

She agrees with Jeudy that Paxton doesn’t have to live a life of upstanding moral character to be embraced by the Christian nationalists. 

Paxton rang in the 2025 New Year in Dubai with his mistress and two fugitives who had been indicted on federal healthcare fraud and embezzlement charges. He also spent the Fourth of July holiday this year in Europe, again with his girlfriend, Christian influencer Tracy Duhon. 

Because of the fraud, bribery and abuse of power allegations that have haunted him for more than a decade, he’s been referred to by his opponent as the most corrupt politician in Texas. 

So how do Christians reconcile the questionable behavior? 

“You’re correct if you suggest that Paxton says these things and does another,” Holzer said. “I don’t think Paxton would say, ‘Adultery is wrong but it’s not wrong for me.’ He may say, ‘Adultery is wrong. I did it. Will you forgive me?’ I hope he would say that.” 

But he hasn’t said that. The candidate hasn’t publicly addressed the fact that he’s married and also has a girlfriend. When someone brings up his pending divorce at a campaign event or one of his rare news conferences, his staff cuts off the questioner and escorts the candidate away. The same goes for questions about how he became a millionaire with 15 homes across the country while bringing in a meager state government salary. 

Michael Emerson, director of the religion and public policy program at Rice University’s Baker Institute, acknowledges that no one in Paxton’s camp or any of his supporters are even acknowledging the corruption allegations, but why would they? 

“There are a couple of ways to explain that away: that the other side was out to get him, even though his own side was voting on that. The second is that he is reformed, so that’s in the past,” Emerson says. “Research shows that fear works best for getting the vote out, and so that’s what they do. You spend a lot less time talking about your own candidate and a lot more time talking about how the world is going to fall apart if the other candidate wins.”

The professor adds that it’s not unusual for people to want representatives who ascribe to their beliefs or values, but the stakes have changed in recent years. 

“When you survey people, economics and lower crime come up a lot, but you always have a religious test,” he said. “We used to want the person to have some kind of character that we agree with. What’s changed is now we want them to fight for whatever our stances are. Whether they have the character seems to matter less and it’s more about: are you fighting for what I care for, religiously?” 

When Paxton’s wife filed for divorce, a reporter asked Emerson if this would end the AG’s chances of being the GOP nominee for the Senate seat. “I said, it does not. It used to,” Emerson recalls. “As long as Christians perceive that he is fighting on their behalf, what he does personally is going to be of less importance. That’s a big change, basically since the Trump era.”  

Fierro-Pérez, says “the debate really isn’t about whether religion belongs in people’s lives or how Christian someone is.”

“It’s about the role that the government should play, particularly in public schools that serve people of many different faiths,” she says. “Both candidates are using their faith as a way to connect to voters but they’re coming at it from very different places.” 

Jeudy notes that it’s natural for people to form their opinions based on life experiences, religion or lack of religion, family and culture. 

“But when you are elected to government office, you are representing a certain population of people,” he says. “You have to take into account all of those people. It takes a special person to be able to do that. It takes strength. You have your opinion, but you understand that, hey, I’m a Christian but I have Muslims in my constituency. I have Atheists. I have Hindus. Those are the people we want to elect, not the ones who will use that position to impose their religion upon everyone else.”

Talarico, who is 37 and has never been married, has also faced scrutiny around his personal life. His critics speculated that he was gay; then, once it was revealed he was in a long-term relationship with his former chief of staff Brianna Menard, they said he shouldn’t have been dating a subordinate.  

Talarico said during a House floor debate in 2021 that God is non-binary, a comment he acknowledged was intended to be provocative and is based on the common theological belief that God is spirit and transcends human categories, including gender. 

Also in 2021, Talarico said, “Modern science obviously recognizes that there are many more than two biological sexes,” suggesting there are six. In a May 2026 interview, he walked it back, saying, “I’ve missed the mark with some of my past statements. There are not six sexes, there are two.”

Paxton supporters pounced on the old video clips, and recent attack ads claim that “Talarico wants to arrest and prosecute parents who don’t support their child seeking gender-affirming care.” Even if he’s elected to the Senate, Talarico won’t have the power to arrest or prosecute anyone, but the fear-mongering appears to be working to get Republicans to the polls to vote against him. 

For those who recognize that boys wanting to share locker rooms with girls or participate in girls’ sports isn’t actually a widespread, rampant practice in Texas, the Paxton camp has another attack: Don’t vote for Talarico because he might, at some point in his life, been a vegan who abstained from eating Texas barbecue. 

The rhetoric is almost comical, Jeudy says, but it shows that the Republicans know they could lose and will cast the net wide to reach undecided voters. 

Holzer says he thinks “the liberals” also have made some non-serious attacks on Paxton. He says he doesn’t think the Democrats actually care that Paxton cheated on his wife. “I think they say this is a good thing for us politically and we can use it to pull a few votes away from him. They’re not really appalled. They can say, ‘See what a jerk he is,’ and they may be right. But let’s pretend Paxton was a saint. They’d still vote against him.” 

“For the other side, they’re not just voting for Paxton,” he adds. “They have a legitimate fear of Talarico’s policies. Talarico is going to support legislation that will treat children as though they are the wards of the state rather than parents’ children and he will protect teachers’ rights to help obtain puberty blockers and transition surgeries against the will of the parents. This is the fear of the right.”

Does Faith Really Matter?

In years past, the hot-button values issues that distinguished between the left and right were abortion and same-sex marriage. That’s now been extended to transgender issues and religious freedom in public schools. 

The social issues aren’t necessarily defined by faith, however, but there are clear dividing lines within the political parties, Holzer says. 

The professor stops short of saying Talarico isn’t a Christian but he says that, based on the candidate’s public statements, he doesn’t think Talarico believes in the virgin birth or the resurrection of Jesus. Talarico addressed his specific religious beliefs on a two-hour 2025 podcast episode with Joe Rogan, on which he confirmed a pluralistic view that different world religions represent pathways to the same truth. 

It was actually Talarico’s pastor, Rev. Jim Rigby, whom the candidate has described as an influential mentor, who allegedly denied a literal bodily resurrection. 

The question is, why is a religious debate even being raised in a U.S. Senate race?

It harkens back to the 1960 U.S. presidential campaign in which John F. Kennedy faced widespread public concern that his Roman Catholic faith would lead him to take orders from the Vatican rather than uphold the U.S. Constitution. 

It’s been brought up in the current Senate campaign of Abdul Al-Sayed, a Muslim from Michigan. On a local level, attack mailers from Harris County judge hopeful Orlando Sanchez supporters claim that if Democrat Letitia Plummer, a Muslim, is elected, she’ll enact Sharia law at commissioners court. 

Emerson says of course each elected official brings their faith and values with them to the office, “and, ideally, in the halls of democracy, they work it all out.”

“You want diversity of views,” he said. “You hope it ends up with the best result. There’s very little chance that, say if a Muslim gets elected and their entire thing is to make this a Muslim nation, they almost have zero chance to succeed at that. At that level, it doesn’t matter what their religion is.” 

Jeudy says the government should operate such that “you bring your values in but leave the religiosity at the door.” 

“If your values are, ‘Do unto others as you would have them do unto you,’ that’s great,” he says. “You leave the supernatural things at the door, but your empathy and compassion form your decisions. Bring it. Bring these great things to that seat. Make decisions based on the ideals, but our government was formed as a secular one. People can pray and believe in their home, in the church, in public squares. That’s great. That’s amazing, but the government needs to stay as secular as possible.” 

Ken Paxton speaks at his Come and Take It Tour in Conroe. Credit: Jack Gorman

Holzer says the way someone governs is dependent on their primary beliefs about “reality, the existence of God and God’s will.” 

“For example, James Talarico is a universalist and has no sense that there’s objective morality for which he might be judged by the Lord of the world. He’s free to take on any ethical view that’s going to get him elected. He’s so quick to embrace transgenderism and same-sex marriage, anything that’s anti-religious, even pro-Islam. Christians have things in common with Islam but recognize there’s a clash of orthodoxies there.”

Holzer adds that Paxton committed a sin by being unfaithful to his wife but Paxton will answer to God. “The Christians can hold Paxton to account for that, but he, at the end of the day, is generally governed by Christian morals and norms. The belief in God governs us,” he said. “Talarico is not governed by God and God’s will.”

Talarico hasn’t shied away from speaking about his faith. In fact, he does it more frequently than Paxton. In a recent email to supporters, Talarico capitalized on the phrase “biblical grounds” used in Paxton’s divorce proceedings.

“I am tired of politicians corrupting my religion to protect their own power and the profits of their billionaire and corporate mega-donors,” Talarico said in his email. “Two thousand years ago, when the powerful few rigged the system, a barefoot rabbi walked into the seat of power and flipped over the tables of injustice. When Jesus healed the sick, he didn’t ask for a deductible. So when I fight for universal healthcare, I’m doing it on biblical grounds. When I say we have a moral imperative to defeat the most corrupt politician in Texas, I’m doing it on biblical grounds.”

Jeudy notes that Paxton’s camp likes to fear-monger when it could be talking about economic policy, immigration, federal funding for natural disasters or “the things he could bring to the table.” 

“I’m not trying to generalize Texas GOP voters, but everybody knows this guy is a bottom-of-the-barrel candidate. He’s awful,” Jeudy says. 

It appears that Paxton has tried to demonstrate his Christian values by filing lawsuits. As attorney general, Paxton has sued school districts for noncompliance with a state law that requires donated Ten Commandments posters to be hung in every public school classroom. He went after a Waller midwife, claiming she was performing illegal abortions, and threatened her with 99 years in prison. Earlier this week, he announced plans for the country’s first detransition clinic to provide medical care to patients under the age of 21 who previously underwent gender transition interventions. 

The intersection of religion and politics is nothing new. Glorious Way Church in Cypress endorsed a slate of three nonpartisan school board candidates last fall, one of whom, Natalie Blasingame, has openly confirmed she’s a Christian nationalist and believes she’s been called to share the teachings of Jesus at all levels of government. All three of the endorsed candidates lost their respective races to trustees who had previously voted in a Democratic primary. 

Both Talarico and Paxton have attended church services on the campaign trail, which is not uncommon for candidates. Black churches have, for years, held public worship services ahead of elections. Bishop James Dixon, senior pastor of Houston’s Community of Faith Church, hosted a “Souls to the Polls” event on October 25. After services, the church had a community block party and congregants rode together to an early voting site to cast their ballots. 

Lakepointe Church in Rockwall held a “How to vote like Jesus” rally in 2024 in which senior pastor Josh Howerton encouraged congregants to vote for Trump over Kamala Harris. The Freedom From Religion Foundation filed a complaint with the IRS specifically targeting Lakepointe and claiming that tax-exempt churches and other charitable organizations can’t use tax-deductible donations for political purposes. 

It’s unclear whether the church’s tax-exempt status was ever revoked. The IRS has not publicly reported any findings or whether it even investigated the matter. Howerton, however, posted on social media recently that while he is “very clear about the evil of many policies being advanced by the [Democratic National Committee], I do not endorse candidates right now.”

“Progressives selectively report churches to the FFRF every year,” Howerton wrote on X. “You’ll never see an article about the primarily [African American] churches Democrats are in every week leading up to the election. It’s an attempt at street-level lawfare.” 

As much as Republicans and Democrats differ on matters of faith, they all appear to agree that this election is important. The Dems are hoping people who are dissatisfied with President Donald Trump will go to the polls to cast ballots against the GOP. Republicans are just hoping their people will go to the polls, period. 

“Democrats are very good at getting out the vote in midterm elections,” Holzer said. “Republicans are notoriously lazy about this. It is their fault if they lose. Texas probably has more conservatives than it has liberals, and I don’t just mean Democrats; I mean liberals of Talarico’s type. Republicans don’t talk to their neighbors. They’re very private about it, and they lose elections out of laziness. They get what they deserve when they don’t show up.”

Staff writer April Towery covers news for the Houston Press. A native Texan, she studied journalism at Texas A&M University and has covered Texas news for more than 25 years. She won the 2025 Association...