Late: A Cowboy Song Sarah Ruhl is one of the most celebrated and awarded names in modern American Theater. Two-time Pulitzer Prize finalist? Check. Tony Award nominee for Best New play? Check. A Pen American Award? Sure. The prestigious and lucrative MacArthur "Genius Grant"? Yup, that too. So yes, the gal's got game, as they say. But chances are you would never have guessed this was going to be the case from her 2003 Late: A Cowboy Song. Written just as Ruhl was on the cusp of critical acclaim, the play, about an ill-matched, dichotomous young couple and the mysterious gender-bending female cowboy who threatens to undo them, didn't have critics widely singing her praises at all. But still, one can make the argument that there is value in paying attention to a marquee playwright's sophomoric efforts even if they're unsuccessful. You may suffer a bit along the way, but you also get to see the genesis of what gets perfected into greatness with more mature output — in this case, Ruhl's trademark sprinkling of the surreal and her ability to create characters she describes as occupying "the real world and also a suspended state." The characters Ruhl works with here are childhood sweethearts Mary (Lindsay Ehrhardt) and Crick (Jason Duga), now a young couple living together somewhere in Pittsburgh in a pre-Internet/cell-phone era. Young not only in age but in emotional maturity (Mary runs to her mother's house the minute a fight breaks out, while Crick thinks sex solves everything), the couple share a birthday and not much else. Crick loves art; Mary could care less. Crick obsessively watches the same old movies over and over; Mary can barely concentrate enough to make soup. Mary works and has some money; Crick is jobless and has none. Mary is always late; Crick is always waiting for her. With so little in common, it's a wonder these two are a couple at all. Yet in Ruhl's hands, as depicted in a series of domestic snapshots, they not only stay together but apparently still have the hots for each other. Fast-forward several creepy groping scenes later, and you get a pregnancy and marriage between the two. Ruhl throws added tension between the couple, first with the head-scratching and utterly unnecessary decision to give Mary and Crick a hermaphrodite child who is surgically altered to become a girl. Then Ruhl throws in a new, intense and secretive friendship between Mary and Red (the easy and charismatic Sara Ornelas), a girl the couple went to school with years ago. Androgynous and living the life of a cowboy outside the city limits, Red is the opposite of Crick. Unshowy and contented in her silences, charismatic and smooth, it's no wonder Mary falls for Red and can finally let her anxieties go. It's here we finally see glimpses of Ruhl's ability to write beautifully affecting yet simple dialogue. As Mary spends more time with Red in these engaging, sexually charged but platonic scenes, she finds it harder to leave her company and becomes purposefully late in returning home to her increasingly jealous/angry husband and infant daughter. Director Bree Bridger does her best to navigate the action between Ruhl's unconvincing realism and lovely but ultimately underdeveloped romanticism. She nicely mines the humour in Ruhl's script and does a fine job of staging Red's whimsical short songs that pepper the show. But a rush job on what should have been a deliciously frenetic whirlwind years' worth of holiday celebrations between Mary and Crick is clunky to the point of sapping all the gleeful energy out of the exercise. The cast all deliver good work in pIaces, and Ornelas's Red is liquid ease that manages to distract from the show's plentiful shortcomings. Duga nicely gives us a Crick who's both a man child and a bully, and Ehrhardt's Mary is an interesting basket of flakey pouts and tics. But ultimately the talented cast cannot plumb the depths of characters that Ruhl has rendered developmentally impotent or just plain implausible. Late: A Cowboy Song is far more successful at evoking moments and feelings than it is at making a point or giving us an intriguing narrative. Overstuffed with questions of gender and sexual politics set against an unsatisfying, surreal examination of marriage and squashed against a fanciful romance, the show tries to be too many things and ends up being not much of anything. Except maybe a glimpse at the seeds of the talent that Ruhl would go on to become. Through November 22. 14 PEWS, 800 Aurora Street, mildredsumbrella.com. — JG