the only living pickpocket in new york
I always feel like/Somebody's watching meeee Credit: Sony Pictures Classics

Title: The Only Living Pickpocket in New York

Describe This Movie In One RoboCop Quote:
CLARENCE BODDICKER: Well give the man a hand!

Brief Plot Synopsis: Veteran thief rips off the wrong guy.

Rating Using Random Objects Relevant To The Film: 3.5 Sal’s Pizzrias out of 5.

Tagline: N/A

Better Tagline: “Accidentally ripping off a mobster seems like it would be more common in New York.:

Not So Brief Plot Synopsis: Harry (John Turturro) has been working the streets of NYC as a pickpocket for quite some time. And for a while, it provided a decent living. But times change. People no longer carry cash, only easily disabled credit cards and phones that constantly broadcast your location. So when he steals a bag containing cash, a USB card, and (more disquietingly) a gun from Dylan (Will Price), he thinks he’s lucked out. What he’s actually done is set events in motion that will have serious repercussions for everyone from his disabled wife Rosie (Karina Arroyave) to his old friend and fence Ben (Steve Buscemi).

“Critical” Analysis: “New York, I love you, but you’re bringing me down.”

The LCD Soundsystem song opening the movie sets the tone for Noah Segan’s The Only Living Pickpocket in New York. Harry loves his city, but is facing a tenuous future thanks to the relentless march of technology (who knew enshittification would come for petty crime as well?). Now he has to worry about things he’s never heard of, much less used, like Etsy or crypto wallets. The guy still relies on payphones to contact friends like Detective Warren (Giancarlo Esposito) and plays LPs for his catatonic wife.

This Luddite atmosphere looms over his acquaintances as well. Warren’s organized crime unit is being shoved aside by the NYPD’s cyber division. The phrase “functional obsolescence” makes an appearance, and applies as much to Harry himself as the antiquated iPods he tries to fence to Ben, whose own computer looks like it dates from the 1980s.

But that’s the macro. On a smaller scale, Harry is an accomplished street criminal, and some tricks never really go out of style. Granted, they’re the ones that got him in trouble in the first place. But there are still analog ways to extricate yourself from a jam. Mostly.

Looking past Harry’s truly amazing Zegna overcoat, it’s clear a life of crime is not without its drawbacks. Aside from caring for Rosie, which provides his only source of consistency, the 60-something Harry still has to hustle 24-7. Add “stealing from a mobster’s son” to the mix, and it all adds up to one bad day.

The technological divide comes to the fore with Dylan and his crew. They’re able to trace Harry’s steps through security camera footage and an ill-advised decision to plug the crypto wallet into Ben’s computer. Meanwhile, Harry moves through the new digital age oblivious to the fact that no one is anonymous anymore.

Although the film is broadly about obsolescence and being left behind by modernity, it’s also shot (and scored, by Gary Lionelli) like classic NYC movies from Spike Lee or Abel Ferrara. The expression “city as character” is overused, but Segan’s decision to film across all five boroughs, along with cinematographer Sam Levy shooting in 35mm, contributes to that nostalgia.

So does Turturro. He’s not only a talented actor, able to wring the range of emotions required, but his hangdog eyes and weathered face recall those great lived-in faces of yore. It’s a hell of a cast all around. As Warren, Esposito brings an affection to the relationship with his old adversary. It’s also a nice oppositional bookend to their first pairing* in Spike Lee’s Do The Right Thing. Price is surprisingly good as the crypto douche bro with Manhattan’s most punchable face. And Tatiana Maslany absolutely nails her one scene as Harry’s *very* estranged daughter.

It’s occasionally *too* on the nose (the “Native New Yorker” scene). And the climactic scene (in the back of a limo) is little more than two veteran actors trading cliches. When all is said and done, however, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is Segan’s love note to a city. A city that never sleeps, and one that moves on no matter how much we may wish it wouldn’t. That comfortable depiction may be at odds with the actual plot, but the emotional impact is undeniable.

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is in theaters today.

*They were also both in Desperately Seeking Susan, but their characters never meet.

Peter Vonder Haar writes movie reviews for the Houston Press and the occasional book. The first three novels in the "Clarke & Clarke Mysteries" - Lucky Town, Point Blank, and Empty Sky - are out now.