When Northside High School suspended 45 students for participation in an immigration walkout, did Houston ISD violate its own discipline policies? And why were Northside students handed three-day suspensions while students at other schools didn’t face the same consequences?
The ACLU of Texas has sent Houston ISD a letter challenging its suspensions of students who participated in walkouts to protest the new immigration orders dispatched by President Trump.
Collecting data from numerous media reports as well as HISD’s own statement following the Northside walkout,ย the ACLU questioned whether HISD had violated its own code of student conduct policies as well as held students to different standards across the district.
“In this case, based on the currently available reporting, it appears that student protestors at someย campuses were harshly punished while there is no indication that student protestors at otherย campuses were punished at all,” said the February 10 letter sent to Superintendent Mike Miles and the Board of Managers members.
HISD described the Northside walkout as peaceful but that 45 of about 100 students were suspended because they did not return to their classes after the protest had concluded and they were told to do so by school teachers and administrators.
According to the ACLU reading of HISD’s discipline policy, nothing the students did at Northside merited their suspensions. Looking at each of the Level I through III offenses, the ACLU states that none of them call for suspension and to be a Level IV โ most serious โ offense would require repeated acts of disobedience or disorderly conduct.
And finally, the ACLU argues, little is achieved and actual damage may be done by removing students from their classes and peers for three days.ย
“Students should not face such severe consequences for peacefully protesting,”
Here is the letter in its entirety:
