The Houston Texans had done a nice job these last two weeks of resurrecting hope in a 2026 campaign that was veering dangerously into โlost seasonโ territory after an 0-4 start, notching division road wins over the Tennessee Titans and Jacksonville Jaguars. Good for them, right?
Well, if youโre looking for a manual on how to rescind all of the optimism and hope generated by those two victories, particularly the last second win over a good Jacksonville team, the Texans authored it on Sunday afternoon, back home at Reliant Stadium, losing in overtime to a New York Giants team over whom the Texans were 10 point favorites.
The Giants were starting J.J. McCarthy at quarterback, a Minnesota Vikings reject whoโd been in the building for the Giants all of about three weeks. That didnโt matter. McCarthy looked in total control. The Giants came into this game with a backfield in total disarray. That didnโt matter. All three of their running backs scored touchdowns, and Cam Skattebo ran for 124 yards.
Itโs becoming quite evident that the โgenerationalโ label attached to this Texans defense before the season is one of the most freezing cold takes of all time. This defense isnโt even in the upper half of the league this season, let alone an all time great defense, and as a result, the Texans head into the bye week with far more questions than answers, sitting at 2-5. Here are Sundayโs winners and losers:
WINNERS

4. Tank Dell
There are very few players that return from the type of multi-ligament knee injury that Dell suffered 639 days ago at all, let alone make it back to play snaps in regular season NFL games. Sunday was a celebration of Dellโs resilience and diligence in making it all the way back. His 43 yard catch and run, and his 14 yard punt return to set up the final touchdown drive were both just icing on the cake for the one โfeel goodโ aspect of Sundayโs game. Tank Dell is back, and in my postgame interview with him, he said he feels like he did before the knee injury.

3. Cam Skattebo
Last week, in the Giantsโ loss to the Saints, Skattebo didnโt get a single carry, a function of both the score of the game and of head coach John Harbaughโs trying to figure out which backs he can trust. The week before, a crucial Skattebo fumble nearly lost a game against the Commanders. (The game ended in a tie.) Sunday, Skattebo completely got his groove back, rushing for 124 yards on 17 carries, including a 16 yard touchdown run where he plowed over half the Texans defense, and a 42 yard run in overtime to set up the game winning score.

2. Kaโimi Fairbairn
The Giantsโ defense was better than the Texansโ defense. The Giantsโ quarterback (more on him in a minute) was better than the Texansโ quaretrback. The Giantsโ special teams were better than the Texansโ special teams. The only position battle the Texans truly won on Sunday was at place kicker, where Kaโimi Fairbairn bailed the Texans out with 58 and 57 yard field goals on two drives, while the Giantsโ kicker, someone named Dominic Zvada missed two field goals.

1. J.J. McCarthy
McCarthy was given the keys to the Giantsโ offense this week, after coming into the loss to the Saints last week, down 34-10, and throwing for 243 yards in just 11 minutes of play. He nearly brought the Giants back, despite four turnover worthy throws, one of which actually turned into an interception. On Sunday against the Texans, he never once pout the football in harmโs way, and was hitting some haymakers down the field. Malik Nabers had 111 yards receiving, and rookie wide receiver Malachi Fields chipped in four catches for 83 yards. McCarthy is probably auditioning for a job somewhere else next season, as the Giantsโ quarterback of the future, Jaxson Dart, is out this season with an ACL tear, but more games like Sunday will probably land him a look from a team needy of a starter in 2027.ย
LOSERS

4. Kamari Lassiter
There are plenty of Houston Texans, especially on defense, that arenโt playing at nearly the level they did in 2025. Nobody, though, has had a bigger drop off than Lassiter, who has routinely been picked on by opposing offenses this season, and whose coverage numbers are atrocious. On Sunday, Lassiter allowed McCarthy to get into a groove early, as he was on the wrong end of coverage against Nabers on a 42 yard catch. For Lassiter, effort is not an issue (unlike some on the defense), as he still plays with a high level of energy, but opposing offensive coordinators are finding him and attacking him.

3. Jamarcus Ingram
When youโre a fringe player that only gets on the field for special teams, you better not be a negative force on special teams. On Sunday, Ingram committed two penalties on special teams, including a completely boneheaded hit out of bounds on a kickoff return with under 30 seconds to go in the half, just after the Texans had tied the game at 14-14, and the penalty gave the Giants field position that helped set up a completely unnecessary field goal attempt before halftime. Luckily for Ingram, Nvada missed the 44 yard attempt, but Ingram canโt commit silly fouls like this. Heโs just not good nor valuable enough to atone for it in other ways.ย
2. Nico Collins
I hate even typing Collinsโ name in a section of a recap with the word โLOSERS,โ and believe me, itโs not because Collins himself did anything wrong in this game. I blame Collinsโ paltry five targets, and even paltrier two catches for an anemic six yards, on offensive coordinators Nick Caley, and his complete inability to find creative ways to get Nico Collins open against a depleted secondary on a blitz happy team. On top of that, Caley couldnโt really spring anyone else open on Sunday by using the attention Collins was garnering. Actually, you know what? Screw this, Collins isnโt the loserโฆ.
2. Nick Caley
There. That makes more sense. Caley sucked on Sunday.
1. DeMeco Ryans
However, Caleyโs coaching job wasnโt the worst one done on Sunday. That belongs to Ryans, who is now the main lightning rod for criticism of the defense, since he started calling the plays again three games ago. Ryans has had just an atrocious 2026 season as the head coach of this team, as the Texans have rapidly started doing things that poorly coached teams do โ commit double digit number of penalties each week, tackle like tackling is optional, commit rampant communication miscues on defense, and play atrociously on special teams. On top of that, there is no incremental schematic or game management edge Ryans is bringing to the table. If anything, his game management is something that the team needs to succeed in spite of. To be clear, I still think there is a good head coach in there somewhere, but in 2026, Ryans is a good coach who is having a disgraceful season.
