Houston ISD mom Jenny Selber Gustafson describes herself as a โproud Jew,โ and someone who pays to send her first-grader to religious classes at a temple to learn the teachings that her family believes.
Gustafson stood before the HISD Board of Managers last week, one of 11 members of the newly formed Say No to Bluebonnet Coalition to do so, and told the panel that the Christian-infused Bluebonnet Learning curriculum adopted in June has no place in public school classrooms.
โOur country is a bold experiment where people of diverse backgrounds can coexist together, and that requires the state to remain neutral on what spiritual beliefs are legitimate,โ Gustafson said. โReligious freedom is essential to our democracy. When the government begins dictating what religious beliefs one ought to hold, it violates that fundamental freedom.โ
Bluebonnet Learning is a state-developed English Language Arts curriculum for kindergarten through fifth graders. Districts can choose whether they want to adopt the lessons. When HISD opted in, the district got $3.3 million from the state.
โThey wanted the money,โ Rabbi Joshua Fixler said in June when the curriculum was approved by the HISD board with little public engagement. โThe state has made this bribe that encourages people to choose this curriculum, and it was too big a number for the district to imagine saying no to, so instead they betrayed our students.โ
The curriculum is plagued with problems, including thousands of typographical errors, missing pages and incorrect answer keys, that will cost taxpayers more than $8 million to correct. More than 300 districts in Texas have adopted Bluebonnet Learning since it was created by the Texas Education Agency ahead of the 2025-26 school year.
The new curriculum comes at a time when Ten Commandments displays are mandated in Texas public school classrooms, school boards are required to consider implementing mandatory prayer time and some educational facilities have chaplains serving as school counselors.
โThe state is increasingly imposing religious elements and instruction onto our schools with a clear agenda: to cement Christianity as a state religion,โ Gustafson said. โThis effort to legitimize Christian nationalism undermines our public institutions.โ
Members of the Say No to Bluebonnet Coalition say theyโre hopeful that since Democratic Gov. Gina Hinojosa was elected earlier this month and has promised to fire TEA Commissioner Mike Morath, the HISD takeover will end soon and the elected board of trustees will be more receptive to the desires of parents and students.
โWe want to make it clear to any future HISD administration that repealing Bluebonnet is a priority,โ Fixler said at the November 12 meeting. โWe want to make it clear that a change is coming in this state and in this country. We will no longer tolerate spaces that should be spaces of inclusion and belonging becoming spaces of exclusion. We will no longer tolerate the influence of Christian nationalism in our schools.โ

Board of Managers president Ric Campo, who was appointed to his position by Morath, said the panel has worked itself out of a job and expects to transition back to elected trustees by mid-January.
Nathan Lonsdale Bledsoe, senior pastor at Bellaire United Methodist Church, told the Houston Press that the Bluebonnet curriculum has first-grade students being โcoercedโ into saying they are followers of Jesus during readings of the Prodigal Son story from the Bible.
Bledsoe has a 3-year-old and calls himself a โfuture HISD parent.โ He learned about Say No to Bluebonnet from Fixler and says heโs encouraging parents who want their children to learn about faith in the home or at a religious institution to opt out of the Bluebonnet lessons.
โAssuming that a public school is for all people and this is a country with a constitution that says we should not have a state religion โ which I believe was established by people of faith as much to protect the church as it was to protect the state โ religious instruction should happen in churches or by religious people in their homes or with their families and their friends,โ he said.
โA public school teacher should not be having to act out the role of Jesus and tell the story of the Prodigal Son to a room full of children with all sorts of faith backgrounds and no-faith backgrounds,โ he added. โWho knows what that teacherโs personal beliefs are? And thatโs not effective. Thatโs not the way to share the gospel. Jesus didnโt have the power of the state on his side, and when he came up against it, he was crucified. Itโs not the way this stuff is supposed to work, at least in terms of this countryโs understanding of how weโre supposed to spread the gospel.โ
Ashley Dellagiacoma, a reverend at St. Stephenโs Church, offered a similar sentiment at last weekโs board meeting, saying the curriculum is subjecting children to โdangerous, coercive lessons.โ
โBluebonnet brings religious teachings into our public classrooms. It presents religious beliefs as facts and centers one particular brand of Christianity to the exclusion of all other religions,โ she said.
Other Say No to Bluebonnet members said the curriculum sends a message to students that Christianity is the only religion worth teaching and suggested that endorsing one religious tradition over others is a violation of the First Amendment of the Constitution, which they say guarantees religious freedom.
HISD dad Aaron Perez said parents have the right to direct the religious education of their children. โReligious instruction has no place in our public schools,โ he said. โStudents in our schools should learn about the many traditions practiced by their neighbors as part of a civic education, but there is a difference between teaching about religion and teaching religion. In many places, this curriculum crosses that line.โ
โStudents of minority faiths will feel alienated by the elevation of these texts and many Christian parents, too, do not wish to have the state usurp their right to direct the religious education of their children. This curriculum tells students what they should believe.โ
After the meeting, Perez told the Press that his wife taught for HISD for 18 years, so heโs intimately familiar with options for teaching kids how to read and tell stories, and using Bible texts isnโt among the best practices. He said he hopes that the change in leadership, both at the state level and local level, will not only bring about the repeal of the Bluebonnet curriculum but also give consideration to smaller class sizes and teacher resource needs.
โOne of my biggest concerns is the privatization of education,โ he said. โWeโre seeing a bunch of charter schools that donโt have the same accountability that public schools do. Iโd like to see more reasonable standards for public schools and for teachers to be given the resources they need to educate the students. Itโs about creating a better environment for the schools.โ
Lynette Ross, who described herself as a community member and ordained minister, told the board that Texas law grants the right to remove a child from any lesson that conflicts with their religious or moral beliefs. โFamilies across HISD will be invoking this right,โ she said.
Bledsoe added that thereโs also a danger in assuming that the State Board of Educationโs interpretation of Christian texts is the same as his or that of people who belong to other Christian denominations.
โWe have diversity of belief within our own denomination,โ he said. โThis curriculum is alleging to be designed as an elementary reading curriculum. Itโs not even social studies or history of religion. Itโs for elementary school kids to learn how to read. I think there are other lessons and stories that kids can learn to read with than the Prodigal Son.โ
He said heโs hopeful that changes to the school board and state leadership will bring about meaningful conversations and positive change, but noted that an unhealthy marriage of church and state is not a partisan issue.
โIt requires everyone to pay attention, no matter who is in the governorโs mansion or the Legislature or anywhere else,โ he said.
