As surreal as it may seem, from 2019 to 2021 six Houston-area refineries were pumping 55 million gallons of chemical-laden wastewater directly into the Houston Ship Channel and other public waterways, and most of them weren’t breaking any rules, according to a new report from the Environmental Integrity Project.
The Washington D.C.-based nonprofit regularly examines publicly available federal Environmental Protection Agency data to highlight regulatory issues. For this study, the EIP focused on analyzing EPA data from 2019 to 2021 for 81 of the nation’s 130 refineries currently in operation, all of them selected because they are dumping their wastewater directly into public waterways.
In fact, all comprised the 81 oil refineries included in this EIP analysis were found to be discharging about half a billion gallons of wastewater to rivers, our streams, and estuaries across the United States daily, enough to fill roughly 700 Olympic-sized swimming pools, and doing so with almost no significant regulation from the EPA, Eric Schaeffer, EIP executive director and former director of the EPA’s Civil Enforcement division, said. “Oil refineries are major sources of water pollution that have largely escaped public notice and accountability in the U.S. and too many release a witches’ brew of contaminants to our rivers, lakes and estuaries,” Schaeffer said.
It won’t likely come as a shock that 30 of the refineries on the EIP list are based in Texas while six of them—ExxonMobil Baytown, Pemex Deer Park, Valero Houston, Chevron Pasadena, LyondellBasell-Houston, and Kinder Morgan Galena Park—are right here in and around Houston. And what’s troubling about them isn’t just that they’re churning out wastewater with almost no oversight. It’s also about what’s actually in the water.
These six refineries alone were pumping an average of 55 million gallons of wastewater laced with cyanide, arsenic, chromium, selenium, and other pollutants per day, according to EPA enforcement and compliance data, with that water going directly from the facilities into the Houston Ship Channel and then down into the Gulf of Mexico. And most of the time it’s been just fine with the folks over at the EPA. It's even legal.
So how is that possible? When these guidelines for water discharge were first established by the EPA in 1974 the idea was that the federal agency would be setting the minimum requirements for refinery wastewater, leaving the responsibility for enforcement and putting in more stringent requirements up to each state.
The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality is charged with issuing permits for industrial air and water pollution and with enforcing federal standards, but that’s a tall order for an entity that is notorious for being, let’s say, business friendly. So it shouldn’t be a surprise that TCEQ officials have never shown much interest in closing that regulatory gap and neither has the Texas Legislature. Right now the EPA is conducting an informal investigation about how the state agency regulates water quality after more than a dozen environmental nonprofits submitted a petition claiming the state barely regulates it at all, according to the Texas Tribune.
On top of that, the EPA regulations that actually are in place were based on the existing wastewater treatment plant technology from the 1980s, the last time the requirements were updated, Tom Pelton, codirector of EIP’s Center for Investigations, said. For refineries this means there are only regulations regarding 10 pollutants. The EPA is required to review and revise its wastewater regulations every five years. Although the most recent review was conducted last month, the actual regulations have not actually been revised since 1985, according to the report. The current regulations don’t even have limits on the amount of selenium, cyanide, benzene or mercury that can be discharged.
And yet despite such forgiving federal standards, 67 of the 81 refineries still managed to surpass the limits set on their pollution permits during the three-year period EIP examined. However, only 15 of those found to be in violation faced any consequences in the form of fines. The Phillips 66 refinery in Sweeny, about an hour south of Houston, violated its water pollution permit 44 times from 2019 to 2021 mostly by dumping cyanide into the Brazos River. They were fined just $30,000.